You'd be insane
NOT to give Favre the shot at the beginning of this season, after last year.
Fact is, Minnesota's problems aren't all Favre. Rice & Harvin have been hurting all year. Rice only
just returned. The Coach hasn't been able to control what he got for lunch, let alone his team. That lead to a switch at the position. Finally, MN's Defense isn't nearly the same as they were a year ago.
All those factors come into play, including Favre being more injured this year than last - and another year older. And thus, you get a bad year.
But I can see why it's so easy to jump on the old QB who won't just die/retire. It's always the QB's fault whenever a team sucks.
Honestly though, are you telling me you wouldn't have started Favre at the beginning of the year if he told you he wanted to return; after the year he gave you last year?