I actually disliked the guy from day one (to put it mildly). Didn't like the look, didn't like the gimmick, didn't like his wrestling, sure as hell didn't like his rapping. But I could tell he was there to stay, much to my chagrin.
He actually made Carlito my favorite wrestler for a short while, when Carlito beat him for the U.S. title on his debut night, because I enjoyed Cena losing in front of his home crowd so much.
Then it came as I feared and Cena entered the main event level, never to leave again.
After years and years of him doing it and carrying the company I can't help but respect the hell out of him, and he did deliver some entertaining moments and promos. But even with all due respect I still just don't like him. At least not enough to happily tolerate him as the top guy year in, year out. I would like him much better if his role on the show was a smaller one.
And to be fair, his character is a so called "white meat babyface." A goody-two-shoes. That's the most difficult role to pull off these days. I don't know if anyone really can do it anymore. Hence the split reaction. A lot of people just don't want their wrestlers to be too nice. They want something more edgy (if I can be forgiven using a meaningless term like that). Yet Cena is sticking to his guns and "rises above the hate." That both increases my respect for him yet again, but at the same time frustrates the hell out of me as well. Cena = Seen it. Time for a change!!! But I digress...
So when did I first start liking Cena? Never did, but the first time he entertained me was probably when he quoted the Geico commercial and said he "just saved a bunch of money on his car insurance." I guess that would be the first time I had to admit that he's got something.