A few weeks ago, Mark Madden wrote an interesting two-part article called "Jump The Shark" (
http://www.wrestlezone.com/editorials/263975-jumped-the-shark). He went into some detail talking about the problems of the current WWE product. And while I know that Mark is extremely controversial and usually comes off as bitter, I think he hit the nail right on the head this time.
Now, I'm not here to compare today's era to The Attitude Era or turn this thread into a b*tchfest, but
I'd like to hear everybody's thoughts on today's WWE product. Specifically, what's missing from it? For me, it all starts at the beginning.
Like many of you, I've been a lifelong WWE fan which spans back to the late-80s. I've been through multiple eras and have seen just about every gimmick imaginable. Let's face it, the WWE has been a part of my life since day 1. Will I ever stop watching? I don't know, but other than a few brief hiatuses, here I am...still watching.
Like many of you who have been watching the WWE for over 20 years, you've obviously grown up and have acquired different interests over time. Some of the WWE characters and storylines that may have appealed to you as a kid or even teenager, may no longer appeal to you now. In addition, you're smarter. You're not as naive. You understand the business and everything that goes along with it. But I have to say...I agree with Mark Madden. I think today's WWE product is at the lowest quality since I started watching.
So the question is...why? Quite frankly, I think the PG rating has absolutely nothing to do with the quality. I think the current crop of superstars are just fine. I think the production quality is top rate. To me, the problem is quite simply the writing. I don't get it. I don't get how Vince McMahon and everybody else at the top doesn't see it. If they want to appeal to the kids, fine. If they want to Tweet and Tout, fine. If they want to align with certain causes, I'm okay with that, too. I am not okay; however, with the creative direction of this company.
I'll give you an example. As a native Philadelphian and Eagles fan, I had to endure one of the WORST Monday Night Football games of all-time. No seriously. Historically, the Eagles and Panthers had the 3rd worst combined records in the history of Monday Night Football. And the game lived up to those expectations. Those two teams stink. I felt like I was watching a preseason game where the outcome didn't matter, and I was just scouting the rookies and figuring out who'd be on the roster next year. The stadium was dead. The crowd was dead. Yeah, Philadelphia fans were dead. They were beaten down so much from the past 14 years that there was absolutely no JUICE in the stadium...and you could tell through the TV.
That's what the WWE is to me right now. It's lifeless. Sure, I watch as a fan but that's only because it's what I'm used to. I like sports entertainment just like I like football. I'm not going to stop watching, but I may stop caring. As a result, I don't attend WWE events anymore. I don't buy merchandise. I don't pay for pay-per-views. Sure, I'll watch Raw on Monday, but I usually DVR it and wait an hour or two so I can fast-forward through all the commercials, recaps, recaps of the recaps, and any other useless material. And if I have something better to do, I'll watch Raw another night...or not. And Smackdown...sure they have some quality "wrestling" matches, but do they even care about the major storylines? Does anything progress? Of course not. It's the B-show. In fact, the pay-per-views of today were what the Raws and Smackdowns were 10-15 years ago.
So will I stop rambling now? Yes. And here is my point. The WWE essentially revolves their entire product around the part-time stars. Everything else is just filler. As Mark states in his article, most of us (and certainly the casual fans) are just waiting for The Rock, The Undertaker, and Brock Lesnar to return...the REAL stars. Honestly, that's what I've been doing. I remember thinking at this past year's Wrestlemania, "Man, I'm so excited that The Rock has finally come back, but what happens the day after Wrestlemania?" And what happened, The Rock said he'd be going for the WWE Championship, and Brock Lesnar returned. And I thought to myself, "Okay. Even if The Rock doesn't actually win the WWE Championship, at least he'll be around here and there. And even if Brock has limited appearances, at least he'll have a few matches." And so what did I look forward to next? Obviously, Brock's return match. And then after? Raw 1000...the next time I'd knew we'd see the real stars again. And then what? Summerslam for Brock's next match. Now, it's the waiting game until the Royal Rumble for The Rock's championship match. Lastly, it'll be for Wrestlemania 29. But then what? I have absolutely no idea...