Hmmm... 12 seems to be the magic number, I started watching weekly starting from their. My first proper match was probably Undertaker vs. Mr. McMahon in a Buried Alive match, so I did really enjoy much before that, including bad ass 'Taker (who looked badass)... I'm 20 now and I feel like I'm in the same boat as you. I'm seriously doubting the WWE's consistency, although I dare not watch.
For about a year or two I stopped watching, it was around 2005 maybe? I stopped right in the middle of JBL's title reign and picked up again near the end of Cena's first reign I think... But there have been some good moments and some good ideas in recent memory though.
I loved the concept of NXT, I know not many people did, but I did. 8 fresh young faces ready for the big leagues competing for their spot, sounds like a great idea, the first two seasons, were absolutely perfect 10-12 weeks long, it all came down to one winner and they earned their place (if even one of the winning pros was Laycool). But of course, they completely f***ed this us starting with season 3, no one wanted to see divas, they're crap, there's a recent why people call their matches 'bathroom breaks'.
Season 4 was complete lack and the winner didn't even move onto to Raw or Smackdown, was that the damn point!? Didn't get his tag team title match either, he might as well have not won at all. And the less said about season 5, the better. Redemption? Instead, how about the caption "WWE's Biggest Writing Block Ever!" The PTP were stuck in purgatory for crying out loud!
Same goes for the Nexus, loved them, thought it was great, a huge step in the WWE. It especially appealed because it was led by an Englishman and I'm here in England, so it was great to see one of out own jump to the main event. But like all good things in the WWE, there was a way to make is fade into obscurity... Each member slowly losing their place and some genius' idea to have Wade leave the group making it so the only surviving member was Otunga for crying out loud! Wade did his best with the Corre, but sadly, this half-baked solution didn't work out well. And you can blame this all on the lamest writing you ever did see...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
I was also wondering about your post, that you should be a little specific of what you don't like now, this is what I didn't like about this weeks: Open show, match with Orton and Ziggler, great beginning, pretty good match... And no, I'm not one of those Ziggler fanboys which are so damn common around here (being able to sell moves sensationally isn't that impressive for me). Anyway, should have had a simple 1 on 1 and when Orton inevitably wins, have Del Rio come out but be too intimidated to go in the ring with Orton standing there waiting for him... It's textbook, simple. But nope, we have to have Del Rio and Ziggler double team him as Kofi (for some reason) comes to the rescue, momentarily forgetting the face that Orton held him a few years ago...
Aaaand here comes T'Lo's music... Surprise surprise, Teddy announces a TAG TEAM MATCH and here's me thinking without him as GM any more this annoying crap won't happen. Anyway, moving on. Later on I come to the Vickie segment, which I seriously had to fast forward (I seriously don't get why people love her so much, they waste so much time on her, they could have a match!) with some cock and bull 'scandal'. I'm hating this storyline so much, just f***ing end it already, it's treating everyone like idiots. I'm also so sick of Vickie being a GM, her shrill voice is on every F***ING show, I cannot get a break! I also can't STAND AJ, again someone who people love but I don't... Her music is so tired and repetitive, not to mention her voice, which has no character and sounds like she's trying to force out a deeper tone (seriously, what the hell is that?). So I fast-forwarded all of that...
And I fast-forward, then I fast-forward... And I fast-forward some more (MY GOD, how much non-wrestling can they jam in this week, another slot of time, wasted).
To be honest I did like the 'Fandango' segments and I can't wait for Curtis to finally come to Raw, I don't care if it's a crap gimmick, it looks pretty funny. I hope it doesn't get old REALLY fast, like the Funkasaurus and his sensationally long entrances which culminates with a fat guy making his way to the ring as slowly as possible trying desperately to dance. Surely by now they can cut out all this crap, it was fine on his debut, but surely he can settle down now into a sort of 'cool guy' who wears funky clothes and has a catchy 80's theme, that's all you need now. I don't even mind Cameron and Naomi still joining him, but you can feel free to develop them a little more then just rubbing their asses together. You can have backstage segments where they express that they're worried about Clay sometimes and stuff, rather then just... "WOOOOO!!!"
Anyway, all of this night comes to a great big f***ing brick wall when they have Paul Heyman pretend to be having a heart attack, purely to mock King. And don't give me any of that s*** that they asked him and he was okay and that controversy is good... There's a difference between creating controversy and being a s*** writer who's being an a**hole. Seriously, there's lines you DON'T cross. If an actor on a soap had a drug problem, you wouldn't decide to just write that into the script! It's just pure laziness by creative because they can't think of anything good or relevant. And you STILL can't tell me it's good TV, because having a middle-aged bald guy pretending to have a heart attack is not why I turn on the TV onto WWE.
Am I done yet? Hell no! Let's talk main event, Punk vs. Cena... Of course Cena rises out the belly of the underdog (yet again) to beat Punk in about 2 minutes. The same guy who couldn't beat Punk and had some sort of build to that fact just blows him about in about 2 minutes without so much as breaking a sweat. Way to make your year long champion look like an idiot WWE, bravo. A year ago Punk was on his way to forcing his way into the WWE's face, telling it how it is! Funny... Reminds me a little of the Nexus, you know why? BECAUSE IT ALL BENEFITS CENA!!! Cena picked about the Nexus and I can pretty much garentee that Cena will win on Sunday because he's SUCH an underdog and SOOOO inspirational. Of course they're gonna screw Punk out of the title the day before hitting one year, why wouldn't they? Instead, let's have Cena hold the title for 2 months then drop it like a hot potato and start this s*** all over again, with Cena being in the main event for WreslteMania, YET AGAIN CHALLENGING FOR THE TITLE!
This is the first time in Punk's reign that I am 100% certain he WILL LOSE. Just look at the end of Raw, Cena and Ryback, both holding the title looking like warriors, as Punk is looking in from the sidelines like a huge bitch.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Anyway I've been venting way too much in this post and I apologise for that, but this is just the tip of the ice-burg for me. There's so much more craptacular stuff in the WWE which I won't go into. But you can surely understand why I'm pissed off, being a guy who brought a 'best in the world' t-shirt and really wanted a Nexus one, but they broke up before I could even attempt to buy one. This company used to have a motto "Entertainment'... Now it's just 'Feed Vince's Cena Stiffy'...
(I haven't proof read this long piece of s***, so sorry if I've made some mistakes...)