Punk doesnt look like a wrestler...
Funny you say that since there's a sure fired hall of famer who, back in WCW, was criticized for not looking like a wrestler and now he's considered a God of sorts...
Punk looks a lot more believable as a pro-wrestler than Mick Foley, and the only reason Foley is accepted is because he came from the disaster pit known as ECW and managed to buddy up with The Rock during the Attitude Era. Oh and the part where he threw himself off of Cell structures... but never has anyone ever said that Foley looks like a wrestler. Wrestlers, like everything in life, come in all colors, shapes, and sizes. You're not going to find two wrestlers that look exactly alike.
As for my WWE Pet Peeve, I would have to say that it's the sudden anti-New Face people that come out of the wood works. It's happened to everybody that's come in the WWE since 2002. From Cena to CM Punk, people in the "IWC" have pandered at how they wanted someone to become champion or get a push... WWE gives them the push, and then all of a sudden there's instant backlash.
Let me clear something up right now. I don't care about people having dislike for certain people... my anger stems from you not saying shit until they get popular. For years, people on the forums were pandering to HoMo and claiming he was "the next HBK". I never once gave him those claims, and I gave off my dislike towards him since day one. I didn't like MNM because Nitro and Melina were terrible. I didn't like Nitro on Raw as IC Champion... I didn't like Morrison as ECW champion. The only time he was relevant to me was when he teamed with the Miz. But that's just it, I didn't wait until a huge band wagon came up and then started disliking him. I knew I didn't like him, so I spoke up. People nowadays will be the same ones saying "Ryback deserves a WWE title shot" or "Randy Orton is the best in WWE" and as soon as WWE pulls the trigger and sends them to the main event people say something like "Randy Orton's title reign is stale" or "Ryback isn't ready to take the WWE title just yet".
It's a stupid concept that people will unfortunately continue to do, because of pure jealousy... but it still bothers the hell out of me. The biggest problem comes from the Anti-Cena fans. They were ALL for Cena when he was the "Doctor of Thuganomics" but when he became the cash cow, people turned on him so quick and so fast that it disgusted me for years.