This really doesn't make much sense. Wins and losses are far less important that you would like us to believe. It's pro wrestling, it's scripted, 99% of the crowd (kids included) understand this.
As for bringing in former stars - calm down, seriously. If the guys of this generation were drawing the way Vince wants them to, he wouldn't need the part-time guys. They're not. Outside of Cena, Orton and Punk, none of them are draws (not including HHH and Undertaker). None of them are considered mega stars, because they're just not that good (Miz, Dolph, Del Rio, Sheamus, the list goes on and on).
Vince and company are looking to make big money, and not many guys on the current roster offer that. I doubt they saw that changing. They know a hell of a lot more than we do, and if they feel this is the best way to make a lot of money, and we get huge stars in return, fuck it. I'm not going to complain about that.
I couldn't possibly care less about who deserves this, or who deserves that. Draw, and you'll be on top. If not, expect someone who can draw to take your spot.