That might only be true due to Roode's low level of charisma. Miz might lack athleticism and such, but he's never lacked a presence or charisma. Roode has the other stuff like technical prowess and the tradional "look" but the charisma thing is average. Case and point, Sting and Roode's promo a couple of minutes ago. Tough to do those because Sting is that much better than Roode at the whole talking thing.
That's why Roode needs a bit more dominance in his wins. He doesn't have the ability to speak like Flair or Miz. But he is much bigger than Miz and Flair. It would be much more believable if Roode looked like he can actually win, but chooses to cheat.