Smackdown is absolutely the B-Show. It has talent, no doubt. But Monday is "wrestling night" in America. Friday is not. Smackdown doesn't get the viewers that Raw does. Smackdown is taped, and that just takes away so much from the feeling of the show, IMO. It starts at 8 PM, and has even more of a "family-friendly" feeling than Raw does. Raw still feels a tiny bit more mature than it's PG-rating.
If they move Orton to Smackdown, I will be very disappointed. Smackdown just isn't Raw. It's not the same. Raw has a live energy to it that Smackdown can never duplicate. I just see this being a terrible move all around. Orton is your fastest rising star. He is skyrocketing to the top right now, with no ceiling in sight...and you want to send him to Friday night?
I understand they need a superstar over there, I get it. Why not send Cena? I know a lot of you Cena marks are going to hate this idea, but I don't care. At this point in time, Cena is a bigger name than Orton. Cena would automatically draw higher ratings on Smackdown than they have right now. All of the little kids would watch, and it doesn't hurt that it starts at 8 as opposed to 9. It could almost be like a little "TGIF" for the t-shirt-buyers. And call me crazy, but I don't think it would hurt Raws ratings at all. People who watch Raw are going to continue to watch Raw without Cena.
I just don't see a reason to take Orton, your hottest guy right now, and throw him onto a show where his arrival might not change anything. I don't think Orton going to Smackdown, at this point in his face turn, is going to draw additional ratings. Cena, on the other hand, would. Personally, I don't want to see Orton over there. I am enjoying the hell out of his character on the edgier Raw show (it's about as edgy as it can get with a PG-rating). I think moving him to Smackdown would A. Not improve Smackdowns ratings (and that is what Vince cares about), and B. Would hurt Ortons push.