Pretty simple question. Do you think he's ready to Main Event against Lesnar? Or should they do something else with him?
I personally would be fine with him winning the Rumble, but I think I'm in the minority on that. I mostly just want him to be accepted by the fans when he is eventually pushed as the next top babyface.
With that in mind, my top 3 choices, in reverse order.
3. Rusev
It'd help Reigns get over as a babyface, and the U.S. Title would definitely be elevated if that were part of the feud. I don't love the idea because I don't really buy Reigns as Captain America or anything and he really isn't skilled on the mic, which IMO is Rusev's strength (I think Lana gets all his heat for him). I'd prefer for Rusev to go against someone a little better on the mic, but if built up properly a WM confrontation between Reigns and Rusev could do both of them a lot of good going forward.
2. HHH
This would assume Undertaker or Rollins gets the match with Sting. I don;t like Reigns against Rollins because as over as Rollins is as a heel, he's a threat to steal smarky fans away from Reigns and I juts don't like when the babyface is the big beast and the heel is the little weasel. It doesn't work that well.
I'd have Reigns enter the Rumble in the ealy teens and be dominating the match, finally clearing house before the final 2 entrants. At this point I'd have HHH interfere and throw him out. The final 2 entrants would be Daniel Bryan at 29, who would start pummeling HHH, and then Seth Rollins at 30 (kayfabe rigged drawing). Rollins would go back and forth for a few minutes with Bryan, HHH would come to and help Rollins, then Sting could return (again) and neutralize HHH, leading to a Bryan win and a happy fanbase. That would set up Bryan vs. Lesnar for the Title, as well as Rollins/Sting and Reigns/HHH at Mania (I prefer this to Rollins/Reigns and Sting/HHH.)
1. John Cena
This is the perfect feud for him IMO. I see lots of mock WM cards that don't have Cena in one of the main singles matches on the card, and that's just naive to project. Cena is getting a big match at WM, and if it's against Rusev I'll be f-king pissed.
I'd use the same storyline where Reigns is dominating the Rumble before coming face to face with Cena. Reigns, Cena, Rollins, Bryan would be the Final 4, and Rollins and Bryan would be outside on the floor and Cena and Reigns could have a big standoff and brawl 1 on 1 for a few minutes.
Reigns overpowers and eliminates Cena, only to be thrown out right after by an opportunistic Rollins. then Bryan eliminates Rollins, etc. and we are on our way.
Cena can come out on Raw, "the future of this company goes through me, Roman Reigns I want you at Wrestlemania." I cannot stress this enough, THIS IS THE BEST WAY TO GET REIGN OVER AS A FACE. The smarks will cheer anyone against Cena. The little kids and ladies will likely go 50-50, but with a good build I think Reigns can get over as a bad boy babyface.
Sure Reigns is bland on the mic but that'll work against Cena. Make that part of the storyline. Cena goes on rants for 2, 3 minutes at a time about how he is the standard in WWE and Reigns can use quick responses about how he's the new sheriff in town and Cena sucks. You think Reigns won't get over if he tells Cena to his face that he sucks every week from the Rumble to WM?
Then WM can be a passing of the torch where Reigns beats the top guy CLEAN and Cena shakes his hand after. I'd even consider a Rock/Hogan scenario where the authority could attack Cena after he loses only for Reigns and Bryan to make the save.
Thoughts? Who would you have Reigns face?