You're kidding right? His match against Diesel wasn't a quality match? What about the No DQ match against Sid Vicious? Have you even seen them? To imply that the Undertaker didn't have any good matches until Kane showed up is just silly.
Nothing impressive about Wrestlemania 3, nope history certainly wasn't made there.
This is where I'm going to point out how biased and blind people are when it comes to Shawn Michaels;
Was Shawn Michaels a good performer? Undoubtedly. But it takes two to tango and Scott Hall certainly wasn't in need of Michaels carrying him, this match is just as much a Scott Hall classic as it is a Michaels one.
Again half of this match is Bret Hart, it's not as though Michaels could've pulled this off with anyone, it needed Bret Hart to be a success.
Again this match wouldn't be a classic without Austin.
Again, this match is only as good as the people involved. Jericho deserves just as much credit for this match as Michaels.
Again, this match contains two other wrestlers who were just as good as Michaels (Benoit was better).
Kurt Angle deserves half the credit.
Now here's a match where HBK deserves the credit, he carried Cena during the match, not to say that Cena's terrible but he certainly isn't at the technical level that Michaels was at. So there he goes, Michaels can have 1.
Again, Michaels can have second victory because he was working with a wrestler who had become rather limited in comparison to what he'd been capable of a decade beforehand.
Both of these matches are quite overrated, I'll give credit where credit is due, the first match was the highlight of that WM. The second one didn't live up to the first but was in no way bad. That being said both guys gave it there all, for arguments sake I'll give Michaels the second match because the Undertaker had become rather limited in the year between the two matches.
It'd be silly of me to imply that these matches weren't good. Because they were, but to me the people involved in these matches were often just as good as Michaels and in the case of Angle and Benoit, I'd say they were overall better.
The argument for "Mr Wrestlemania" is a bit difficult, seeing as it's generally based on match quality and it's incredibly rare for a match to be of particularly high quality on the back of a single person. Which is why I personally don't feel that the title belongs to anyone. However in the spirit of the thread. the following are people who've had multiple classic matches at Wrestlemania who could be considered "Mr Wrestlemania";
Chris Jericho
Chris Benoit
Kurt Angle
The Rock
Stone Cold Steve Austin
Kevin Nash
Scott Hall
Bret Hart
Shawn Michaels
The Undertaker
Hulk Hogan
Randy Savage
And there are others. Attributing that sort of title to someone is borderline impossible because a truly good match needs two amazing wrestlers, which is why no one man is worthy of holding that title.
I agree, it takes two to tango. If u got people like Razor Ramon, Diesel, Bret Hart, Stone Cold, Chris Jericho, Chris Benoit, Triple H, Kurt Angle, John Cena, and Undertaker as your Wrestlemania opponent of course you're bound to have great matches at Wrestlemania. If not, then you're completely a f*cked up performer like Triple H & Randy Orton, two men with array of great opponents but only got not more than 1 or 2 Wrestlemania classics. Triple H's Wrestlemania classics are only against Undertaker at Wrestlemania X-7 and against Chris Benoit & Shawn Michaels at Wrestlemania XX. Just look at Shawn Michaels' match with El Matador at Wrestlemania VIII or Tatanka at Wrestlemania IX, he didn't steal the show right? Right, because his opponents weren't good at all.
If u want to bring up his match against Vince at Wrestlemania XXII or Flair at Wrestlemania XXIV, I want to say those two matches are two of the most overrated matches I've ever seen in my life. And tha also shows how PWI and most of Shawn Michaels fans could be sooooo biased when it comes to him. Edge vs Foley OWNED Wrestlemania XXII, my god it was such an underrated match!
And as for Wrestlemania XXIV....The vast majority of people have said Ric Flair or Shawn Micheals, which I fully understand, but I think that the performance put on by The Undertaker and Edge is often overlooked. I re-watched that match recently, and it was outstanding, by far the best match on the card that night.
People remember the Flair retirement from that night. They remember CM Punk winning Money in the Bank. Some even remember Floyd Mayweather vs. The Big Show. All of those were important matches, but The Undertaker and Edge put on a true main event worthy performance that always seems to get lost in the shuffle. I mean, I'd even go so far as to call it a classic. I think that most people had a pretty strong inclination that The Undertaker would win, but it was exciting all the way through, it had a ton of great twists and turns, it had some great near falls. Overall just a great, great match.
On the whole, Wrestlemania 24 wasn't a spectacular pay-per-view. There have been plenty of 'Mania events before and hell, even since, that have far outstripped it. However, that was an excellent match and main event worthy.Undertaker vs Edge is THE best Wrestle Mania 'WRESTLING' match since Angle vs Michaels. Edge reminded everybody that he's one of the best in the business & not just a transitional champion. He was actually more dominant over The Undertaker than anybody else has ever been at a Wrestle Mania. Edge reversed almost every Undertaker move and what made the match even more interesting was the less predictable finish which saw The Dead Man win via submission instead of The Tombstone that EVERYBODY was expecting him to win by. Wrestling quality wise, this match is on another planet compared to Shawn Michaels vs Ric Flair in a 'retirement' match(which doesn't hold any meaning by now cause Flair wrestled again in TNA).
Those who aren't clouded by hype could tell Undertaker vs Edge is comparable to any technical wrestling matches in masterpiece level. It surpassed my expectations and was extremely intense. This was a great main event that truly culminated the whole night just into one match. Edge tried to have everyone help him keep his title, but Undertaker in an unreal state takes them all on. You can feel the intensity, the rivalry and the hype behind this match. Lots of nearfalls and counters made this match just plain enjoyable and pure entertainment.
The first half of the match featured many counters and reversals, including Edge reversing Old School, the Chokeslam, and the Last Ride. The match picked up the pace big time later on. Undertaker hits the Chokeslam and Last Ride, but fails to get the pin on both. Undertaker later attempted a big boot but hit the referee instead, this gave Edge the opportunity to nail Undertaker with a video camera. Undertaker gave Edge a Tombstone Piledriver afterwards, but the ref was still out so as Undertaker pinned Edge, a new ref had to sprint down the entrance ramp to make the count. Unfortunately, this gave Edge enough time to kick out. Edge later hits a spear, but Undertaker suddenly locks Edge in his new submission hold immediately after. After hanging in for a while, Edge submits and The Undertaker wins the World Heavyweight Championship at WrestleMania for the second straight year. A WrestleMania classic and amazing match. Edge is a surefire Hall of Famer, he is worthy to be included on the list. I dare say this match is as good or maybe even better than their match at Summerslam 2008.
I agree with anyone labeling this match as the most underrated Wrestlemania match of all time. I can't believe horrible matches like Undertaker vs Giant Gonzales at Wrestlemania IX, Undertaker vs Big Boss Man at Wrestlemania XV, and Undertaker vs Mark Henry at Wrestlemania XXII made it to wweclassic but this match didn't! That alone proves how overlooked this gem is.
Hogan pretty much put Wrestlemania on the map, while Taker had to deal with five talentless giants who destroyed nearly all the credibility The Streak had, of course I'm talking about Giant Gonzales, King Kong Bundy, Big Boss Man, A-Train, and Mark Henry.
So, yeah, Michaels is Mr. Wrestlemania but only cause he got array of great opponents to tango with.
And the last but definitely not the least, I believe The Undertaker is the most underrated Wrestlemania performer of all time. His match with Diesel at Wrestlemania XII, Sid at Wrestlemania XIII, Ric Flair at Wrestlemania X-8, Randy Orton at Wrestlemania XXI, and Edge at Wrestlemania XXIV are all criminally underrated matches which will never get the recognition they deserve. Ever.
Try.. The Ladder match at WM X... The Iron Man match at 12. Triple threat at XX.. Angle at 21. Flair at 24.. Taker at 25.. Taker at 26 probably.. And thats not just my opinion... 
