If I said no, he wasn't a plant, and there truly are 1 in a dozen freaks in this world and Lovitz simply pulled an ace out of the hole.. would you believe me? OF COURSE NOT. Yes, he was clearly a plant. I think the Star search winner should be Lovitz for merely remembering which 'plant' he was once things went live.
As for whether segments such as these should continue? No. Hell no. OH HELL NO. Not only is it a waste, its completely pointless. What point did this serve? To further mock Ted Dibiase by finding some random "fan" that turned his offer to buy something, down? Or to have Santino apply a modified vulcan death grip on Virgil? Maybe, just maybe, it was to waste 10-15 minutes of air time, because they're trying to cover up the belief that they don't actually have enough faith in their talent to fill the void?
Regardless of the reason, segments are nice.. but ones like these are purely stupid, pointless and serve NO reason on a Wrestling show. None.