ECW Toronto, Round 3, Match 1: #3 Edge vs. #14 Raven | Page 2 | WrestleZone Forums

ECW Toronto, Round 3, Match 1: #3 Edge vs. #14 Raven

Edge vs. Raven

  • Edge

  • Raven


Results are only viewable after voting.
It's all very well saying that Edge was pushed to his very limit but this could all be very scripted, maybe he was just selling the match very well. I dunno. The thing that is getting me is that it doesn't really matter which region the match is in, only the stipulation. an Extreme rules match. For me, where as Raven may be comfortable in this match type, Edge has had his fair share or extreme matches. How many Hell in a Cells, Elimination chamber, last man standing matches has he been in? Quite a few by my reckoning. Let us also not forget that Edge made his name in a very brutal and extreme match, that is TLC. Edge may not be used to Extreme Rules matches but he is more than capable of winning in a match which is extreme. If this is the case it then comes down to who would be able to take more advantage of the stipulation. In my opinion, this would be Edge. The man is the Ultimate Opportunist. I think Edge wins.
 
Fact of the matter is, this match is in ECW. Where did Raven make his name: That's right- ECW.

All I'm saying is that ECW was shit. So what does that make Raven: That's right- shit.

The only reason Raven is supposedly a better hardcore wrestler then Edge is because he's been in a lot more hardcore matches. All that proves to me is that he wasn't good enough to do anything else. I'm sure if Edge wanted to be nothing more then a hardcore wrestler then he could have been, but the fact is he's better then that and he's better then Raven. Whether it's ECW, WWE, WCW, or my backyard it doesn't change the fact that Edge is better then Raven.
 
I think Edge would make more use of the extreme rules opportunity. Vote: Edge
No offense but I think your wrong. Raven is known for weapons, Edge is hardcore but not Raven hardcore. Raven would walk in with a chair and that's just to start the match. Edge is known for using ladders tables adn chairs. Raven is known for crucifying sandman, using barbed wire, chairs, tables, fire and he invented hangman's horror and a match known as the clockwork orange house of fun. So, no Edge wouldn't take more advantage of the extreme rules if anyhting he would take less of an advantage. Vote: Raven
 
There really isn't that much to say. Edge is hardcore, in the way that being chokeslammed "to hell" is hardcore. He can do it in WWE, but thats nothing like ECW. Raven eats, sleeps, and breathes pain and suffering, and loves inflicting it on others.
Ravens playground of ECW, Raven's rules (although that was WCW), the Flock/Gathering/Serotonin probably at ringside. Vickie can't save you now Edge.
 
I knew this would happen, but there we go. Raven does not win this match. I understand that he was hardcore in ECW, and I appreciate that, but look at his record in gimmick matches against big named wrestlers, and it doesn't make for good reading, guys like the Big Show completely wiped the floor with him in the WWE.

Edge on the other hand has not only beaten ECW alumni like RVD, Rhyno and Tommy Dreamer decisively, he has also beaten some of the biggest names in pro wrestling history, and if not that, of this era, in gimmick matches. Foley, Cena, Undertaker, Kane, Batista. I appreciate that Raven's wins were against guys more suited to that environment, but Edge is renown for using weapons, so it's not as if this is Frank Gotch against New Jack in the hardcore wrestling stakes.

I just don't think Raven was ever good enough to take it to the huge names in wrestling, as exemplified by his abortive attempts at success in WCW and WWF/E. It'd be an excellent match, but I think Edge pulls this one off.
 
I knew this would happen, but there we go. Raven does not win this match. I understand that he was hardcore in ECW, and I appreciate that, but look at his record in gimmick matches against big named wrestlers, and it doesn't make for good reading, guys like the Big Show completely wiped the floor with him in the WWE.


Edge on the other hand has not only beaten ECW alumni like RVD, Rhyno and Tommy Dreamer decisively, he has also beaten some of the biggest names in pro wrestling history, and if not that, of this era, in gimmick matches. Foley, Cena, Undertaker, Kane, Batista. I appreciate that Raven's wins were against guys more suited to that environment, but Edge is renown for using weapons, so it's not as if this is Frank Gotch against New Jack in the hardcore wrestling stakes.

I just don't think Raven was ever good enough to take it to the huge names in wrestling, as exemplified by his abortive attempts at success in WCW and WWF/E. It'd be an excellent match, but I think Edge pulls this one off.


Raven takes this match in one of the biggest frenzies the world has ever seen. This is why...

[youtube]TOj1ZbKd5uA[/youtube]

This is in ECW. If this was in WWE...Edge wins hands down. But not here, buddy. And not just Raven would win...Sandman, Sabu, RVD, even Taz would beat Edge here. It's the ULTIMATE home field advantage. The ECW kind of fans hate Edge and would do anything to make sure Raven took home the win. Raven wins with an Evenflow off of a folding chair. Then a riot ensues. Seriously.
 
Raven takes this match in one of the biggest frenzies the world has ever seen. This is why...

[youtube]TOj1ZbKd5uA[/youtube]

This is in ECW. If this was in WWE...Edge wins hands down. But not here, buddy. And not just Raven would win...Sandman, Sabu, RVD, even Taz would beat Edge here. It's the ULTIMATE home field advantage. The ECW kind of fans hate Edge and would do anything to make sure Raven took home the win. Raven wins with an Evenflow off of a folding chair. Then a riot ensues. Seriously.

I'm voting Raven over Edge but I dont think that the fans should be thrown in an argument for Raven, because remember this is Toronto,Canada...and even though Edge is a heel they will still cheer for him.

Now...Raven would probably be boo'ed out of the building for what he is going to do to Edge...but I don't think that is going to affect the match much because he has probably been with Crazier crowds, so I think he could Handle a Canadian Crowd.
 
Who says that the fans would make a difference at all? Edge has been a heel for the majority of his career. He relishes when the fans hate him. It drives him, fuels him. It helps him. I agree that Raven has an advantage in E.C.W. Edge still is no slouch. He's a 9 time world champ for a reason; he knows how to win. Edge gets his ass kicked most of the match, but he always, always, always finds a way to pull out the W. I know that's a cheap argument, but it's true.
 
This is the biggest joke I've seen yet, in this entire fucking tournament. Including H.B.K dropping to Liger. Raven was a legend in the land of Extreme, but it wasn't because he was "untouchable" or "Godly", it was because he fought a who's who of drunken bar mice and untalented losers.

Who'd he ever fucking defeat time and time again? Tommy Dreamer? And what exactly did Dreamer DO in E.C.W? He fucking put people over. So naturally Raven was going to own him time and time again, until the final match Raven had before leaving for W.C.W, in which he still (if even) put Dreamer over.

Sandman, and the barbwire match.. uhm.. that's great and all, but this match doesn't involve the ropes being pure barbwire, so WHY THE FUCK DOES IT MATTER?! Besides all that, you ignorant Raven voters act as if Edge hasn't dealt w/ Barbwire before.. recall his Mania match against Foley, enough said. And before anyone says "barbwire ropes > barbwire bat".. ITS NOT A FUCKING BARBWIRE ROPES MATCH! (short of Raven wasting all the time, lining the ropes w/ it)

Edge IS the ultimate opportunist, that being said.. he finds the openings needed and capitalizes. He fucking defeated the Undertaker in an anything goes T.L.C match (how isn't important, since Raven's won just as many matches in similar fashion - the only difference, Raven hasn't beaten anyone with the skill set of a Cena, Taker, or Triple H.. Edge has)

So because it's a hardcore environment, Raven is meant to have the advantage? Uhm, no. Edge isn't a fucking spring chicken. He didn't just join the dance yesterday, he's been around the block and has had some of the sickest hardcore, bloody and violent matches W.W.E's ever put on.

Once again, don't give me that shit about how E.C.W has put on greater. Yeah, hardcore wise I'm sure they did.. to cover up the severe LACK of talent the overall Wrestlers had. Thus, Edge has talent and the ability to wrestle in a hardcore element.

Edge takes this match, EASILY! Raven won't catch him in a DDT, because Edge used to use an impaler DDT, thus he'd know how to reverse it. Raven wasn't one for "suddenness", so that won't be a problem with being caught out of nowhere, either. Edge, on the other hand.. holds the one thing Raven can't counter.. talent, and sudden-impact moves.

Edge can hit a spear with Raven not even knowing it's happened before the official tells him he's lost.

Do the right thing. Think before you vote. Just because Raven was famous in an extreme world, doesn't mean Edge can't still take him down. He can, he will, and fuck all.. Edge holds twice as much talent, size, strength, speed and intensity than Raven ever has. VOTE EDGE!
 
Remember, though, that whenever WWF guys went over to ECW for a little cross-promotion...the ECW guys seemed to always find a way to win. It would seem that the home field advantage of ECW is something very "real."
 
I agree wit hthe big Edge post above, hoem field advatnage can onyl take you SO far. No way Raven, a career nobody compared to Edge, wins here. Edge is the top heel in the biggest company in the world. Edge has beaten "supermen" like John Cena and future legends like Triple H and The Undertaker. Raven made his name in a third rate promotion, and it doesn't matter if he can use weapons - Edge knows hwo to use them too, and tbh everyone knows if this match ever happened, with both in their primes, Edge would be put over.
 
No way Raven, a career nobody compared to Edge, wins here.
LOL, this statement makes me laugh. So because the WWE puts the title on Edge 9 times in 3 years, he's suddenly a Legend? What a joke. He's won the belt 9 times, and barely has a full year worth of total days as champion under his belt. Just because Edge is so terrible he loses the belt all the time, doesn't make him a legend.

Edge is the top heel in the biggest company in the world.
No, Orton is.

Raven made his name in a third rate promotion
So? The fact of the matter is that not only was he successful in ECW, he was also successful in WCW, he won titles in WWE, and he was a World Heavyweight champion in TNA.

Calling Raven a career nobody is absurd.



The fact of the matter is this. On what basis, aside from the fact that Edge seems to lose title matches quite often, can you vote for Edge over Raven? Edge doesn't play his character as well, he's not as good in the ring, he is comparable on the mic (maybe), and he's no where near as interesting. Don't get me wrong, I can't stand ECW, but saying that Edge is better because he is horrible in title matches is just a silly argument. The only reason Edge is in the main-event is because the WWE put ALL of their creative energies into Edge. They pushed him and pushed him and pushed him to become a main-eventer, and he failed over and over and over again. It wasn't until they finally had John Cena make him look good was Edge finally able to be considered a legit main-eventer. With the type of support and backing the WWE gave Edge, Raven could have been a 9 time World Champion too.
 
Slyfox696 said:
So? The fact of the matter is that not only was he successful in ECW, he was also successful in WCW, he won titles in WWE, and he was a World Heavyweight champion in TNA.

He held the US title for a day in WCW, and beat none of the big names there, except for DDP, ut that was before DDP reached the higher echelons of the company. If by titles you mean winning the Hardcore championship, then yes Raven won titles in WWE, but so did Pete Gas, and one of the Godfather's hos. Also, it means Crash Holly was a 22 time champion. Even in TNA he only held the title for 2 days, a record shortest reign in that promotion.

Edge's nine reigns may have only lasted a combined 400 days or so, but Raven's combined NWA Championship in TNA, 27 hardcore championships in WWE and one each US and Light Heavyweight WCW title reigns weigh in at a stonking 118 days. So, if anyone is bad at title matches, it's Raven.

Calling Raven a career nobody is absurd.

I'm inclined to agree with this, but to state that he somehow is better than a multipe time world champion because he has won the Hardcore championship is ridiculous.

The fact of the matter is this. On what basis, aside from the fact that Edge seems to lose title matches quite often, can you vote for Edge over Raven?

In Edge's career he has beaten some huge names. He has beaten a lot of them in a hardcore environment. Who has Raven ever beaten that is on the same level as Cena or the Undertaker? If he had stayed in ECW his whole career, then maybe I would have bought that he could keep up with the big boys, but he clearly couldn't. With an entire stable onside, Goldberg fucking demolished him on WCW, and he went on to lose to guys like Perry Saturn.

In WWE he lost feuds to Tommy Dreamer, and ended up as a Heat mainstay. If that doesn't prove that he can't keep up with legitimate main eventers, then I don't know what does.

Edge doesn't play his character as well
,

I'm not sure that is entirely true, I think Edge does play his character very well, but even conceeding that point, so what? Why does a wrestler even need a strong character? Even conceeding that point, what does it matter. Goldust plays his character very well, there are a lot of videos on youtube claiming it "proves" that wrestling is homoerotic. However, remind me the big wins he's ever had? Less faecetiously, Ted DiBiase played his character superbly, but he lost to Virgil, who was shit at everything, as well as just about every top face of the era.
he's not as good in the ring

Neither is Goldberg, but he beat him fairly easily.,

he is comparable on the mic (maybe)

Right.

, and he's no where near as interesting.

Again, so what? Randy Orton is as boring as they come, but he is the top heel in the company.

Don't get me wrong, I can't stand ECW, but saying that Edge is better because he is horrible in title matches is just a silly argument.

I don't have a problem with the majority of ECW's bigger names, and I'm not saying Edge would win because he won 9 world titles. I'm saying Edge would win because he has beaten some huge names in pro wrestling lore, while Raven has beaten Tommy Dreamer. It just doesn't compare.
The only reason Edge is in the main-event is because the WWE put ALL of their creative energies into Edge.

Who has ever walked into the main event and been a success story? Everyone needs a push, and Edge was certainly more over in his early career than Randy Orton and Batista were before they joined Evolution, or HHH was before DX or just about anything. The argument that the WWE pushed him is moot, of course they did. In a fake sport, how can they not have a world champion that has been pushed. They chose to push Edge. It's not as if they have some vested interest in Edge's success. Edge and Christian started at the same point, but Edge got the push because the company thought he was better.
They pushed him and pushed him and pushed him to become a main-eventer, and he failed over and over and over again.

At least he was good enough to be pushed in a major company, which is more than can be said for Johnny Polo.

It wasn't until they finally had John Cena make him look good was Edge finally able to be considered a legit main-eventer.

Sorry, why is anyone seen as a legitimate main eventer in wrestling. I was under the impression that it happened when they beat big named wrestlers. You know, like when Cena beat Jericho.

With the type of support and backing the WWE gave Edge, Raven could have been a 9 time World Champion too.

But he wasn't given thee support was he, because Vince McMahon saw a hell of a lot more in Edge than he did in Raven. It would appear that Bischoff and Russo didn't see much in him either. Or indeed any booker except for Paul Heyman. Raven was certainly an interesting character, but it isn't really his matches that are remembered but his mind games.

There is none better than The Undertaker when it comes to mind games, and Edge beat him. It's as simple as that for me really, Edge wins this because he has beaten some huge names and Raven has always come up short against the bigger names.

As for the crowd. I think it's a little bit of a daft argument. Firstly, an ECW event in Toronto wouldn't have the same ECW fans as the actual ECW, and secondly, wasn't Raven a massive heel in ECW? I'm pretty sure they wouldn't be that behind him.

You can say what you want about the ECW crowd, but I have to say, I think their perceived impact is bullshit. When Awesome came back to lose the title to Tazz, there was a few "you sold out" chants, but it was hardly hell on earth for Awesome. It's certainly something exaggerated by history, and even when it did exist, it was in the ECW bingo hall, where this match isn't.
 
The fact of the matter is this. On what basis, aside from the fact that Edge seems to lose title matches quite often, can you vote for Edge over Raven? Edge doesn't play his character as well, he's not as good in the ring, he is comparable on the mic (maybe), and he's no where near as interesting. Don't get me wrong, I can't stand ECW, but saying that Edge is better because he is horrible in title matches is just a silly argument. The only reason Edge is in the main-event is because the WWE put ALL of their creative energies into Edge. They pushed him and pushed him and pushed him to become a main-eventer, and he failed over and over and over again. It wasn't until they finally had John Cena make him look good was Edge finally able to be considered a legit main-eventer. With the type of support and backing the WWE gave Edge, Raven could have been a 9 time World Champion too.


Firstly, saying that Edge does not play his character as well as Raven is absolutely absurd. Edge has been a pretty well over heel for most of his career with WWE. This is especially true when he became a main event superstar. The guy sells the stories he is in. I remember being so cross when he beat Undertaker in the match that Undertaker had to retire. The man can sell a character as well as anyone in the WWE, or anywhere else for that matter.

Secondly, are you seriously saying that Raven was better in the ring than Edge? Without a lie? Come on man think about. I for one don't see Edge botch moves on a regular basis, not that Raven does, but Edge is a great in-ring worker. No doubt about it. Saying that Raven is better in the ring is crazy. I don't see a lot of Raven but when I do, he doesn't keep me watching or nearly as interested as Edge does.

Thirdly, There is a reason why the WWE put all of their creative talent onto Edge, because they knew he could handle being in the ring with guys like Cena, Batista, Orton and Triple H. he has pure talent. There is also a reason why he is a 9 time World Champion. Because he deserves to be. The guys is a great heel and in terms of wrestling and mic skills he is one of the best in the WWE.

That last point was just silly.

Vote EDGE
 
This is the biggest joke I've seen yet, in this entire fucking tournament. Including H.B.K dropping to Liger. Raven was a legend in the land of Extreme, but it wasn't because he was "untouchable" or "Godly", it was because he fought a who's who of drunken bar mice and untalented losers.

Or maybe it was because he was really just that danm good, trying to bury and entire company the guy was successful in is just a cheap move Will, I expect better from you, especially since knowing you you prolly have loads of ECW tapes in that massive cabinet thing you say you have

Who'd he ever fucking defeat time and time again? Tommy Dreamer? And what exactly did Dreamer DO in E.C.W? He fucking put people over. So naturally Raven was going to own him time and time again, until the final match Raven had before leaving for W.C.W, in which he still (if even) put Dreamer over.

I already countered this argument, perhpas you should go back and read some more posts before you start spewig the same horseshit as all the other Edgeheads, he's beaten the likes of Terry Gordy & Dr. Death Steve Williams, two guys that are legends in this business, as well as taking Terry Funk to the limit, and nearly beating him(in a match that was far more brutal than the WM Hardcore match w/ Foley), the only reason he lost that match was do to outside interference by Dreamer

Sandman, and the barbwire match.. uhm.. that's great and all, but this match doesn't involve the ropes being pure barbwire, so WHY THE FUCK DOES IT MATTER?!

Because IT SHOWS HIS TOUGHNESS, AND THAT HE IS ABLE TO WITHSTAND FAR MORE PUNISHMENT THAN SOMEONE LIKE EDGE

Besides all that, you ignorant Raven voters act as if Edge hasn't dealt w/ Barbwire before.. recall his Mania match against Foley, enough said. And before anyone says "barbwire ropes > barbwire bat".. ITS NOT A FUCKING BARBWIRE ROPES MATCH! (short of Raven wasting all the time, lining the ropes w/ it)

Oh please Will, you and I both know he dealt with very little barbwire in that match, Raven has survived much much more pain, suffering, and blood loss than Edge could ever dream of, Edge took out a broken down Foley, the guy was only a shell of his former self, and it took everything Edge had to beat him, Raven is far more sick and twisted, he's far more calculating in how he uses his tools of pain than a semi-retired Foley is

Edge IS the ultimate opportunist, that being said.. he finds the openings needed and capitalizes.

Edge isn't the ulimate oppertunists he's more like the ultimate pussy, if anything he just gets lucky, the big reason for most of his success on SD! was due to him fucking the GM, pretty sure he won't be able to do the same with Heyman...or at least I hope not

He fucking defeated the Undertaker in an anything goes T.L.C match (how isn't important, since Raven's won just as many matches in similar fashion -

Kinda countered your own argument there, good job:thumbsup:

the only difference, Raven hasn't beaten anyone with the skill set of a Cena, Taker, or Triple H.. Edge has)

When the hell has Edge ever beaten Triple H?

So because it's a hardcore environment, Raven is meant to have the advantage?

It is kinda his thing, so yeah

Uhm, no. Edge isn't a fucking spring chicken. He didn't just join the dance yesterday, he's been around the block and has had some of the sickest hardcore, bloody and violent matches W.W.E's ever put on.

None of which compare to the level of violence he would face in a match with Raven in ECW

Edge takes this match, EASILY!

:lol:Yeah that's a load of bullshit, and your biased Edge loving ass knows it


Raven won't catch him in a DDT, because Edge used to use an impaler DDT, thus he'd know how to reverse it.

Many know how to reverse it and yet Raven still hits it on them, not too mention Raven doesn't useally go for this move until the end of that match after his oppeant has been beaten down and has lost several pints of blood

Edge can hit a spear with Raven not even knowing it's happened before the official tells him he's lost.

And Raven can whack Edge in the head with a steel chair as he's running to hit the spear, not to metion I'm not so sure Edge will be able to stand by that point in the match, ya know losing all that blood and all

Do the right thing. Think before you vote.

Yes exactly Will, YOU should think before you vote, don't let your blind love affair for Edge make your decision for you
 
Or maybe it was because he was really just that danm good

But Raven isn't that good. He was just the best out of a bunch of guys who never really did anything in their careers.
he's beaten the likes of Terry Gordy & Dr. Death Steve Williams, two guys that are legends in this business

Yea he beat them when they were both out of shape and not in their prime. The only reason Steve Williams was undefeated in the U.S. for almost a decade was because he was in Japan for most of that time and when he did go to the U.S. it was mostly doing indy shows. It's not like he was in a major promotion. I'll take a win over an older Mick Foley over wins against Terry Gordy and Steve Williams.

as well as taking Terry Funk to the limit, and nearly beating him(in a match that was far more brutal than the WM Hardcore match w/ Foley), the only reason he lost that match was do to outside interference by Dreamer

I'm glad he took Funk to the limit but a loss is a loss.
The fact of the matter is that not only was he successful in ECW, he was also successful in WCW, he won titles in WWE, and he was a World Heavyweight champion in TNA.

Raven was the U.S. champion for one fucking day. That doesn't impress me at all. Especially considering the fact he needed all of Raven's flock to get the title in the first place. Raven was a complete failure in WCW. I mean his only good feud was with his ECW buddy Sandman. And he didn't win titleS in WWE. The only title he won was the hardcore title, and the WWE hardcore title was the biggest joke I've ever seen. When he won the heavyweight title in TNA it was during a time when guys like Sean Waltman were competing for the title. Even Ron Killings held the title during this time frame.
 
Bollocks is Raven even above average. The fact that only guys on the internet give as hit about him shoukd be proof enough. The guy sucks compated to Edge, even in Edge's tag wretslers, one of the greatest kayfabe tag wrestlers of ALL TIME. Raeven maybe "hardcore" but it's not a massive deal - would you put Taz over Hogan merely because itwas ECW? Fuck that shit. Everyone knows Edge and La Familia would beat the crap out of Rave. Are tou honsetly saying Raven is better than The Undertaker? Fuck that shit. The Unddertaker lost to Edge in TC (basically no rules). No way does Raven "I can'tdowrestle so I use weapons" ADvANCE here - the guy is second rate at ABSOLUTE BEST. Edge, the NINE TIME WORLD CHAMPION would win here in a Royal Rumble title match that would be as predictable as Lesnar v Hardcore Holly.
 
At the apex of Edge's career, he has Chavo Guerrero, Bam Neely, and the Edge-heads to fight for him as well. Do any of you actually think that Raven (who in his prime had no one but himself) can overcome a former E.C.W. champion, a 6'9 280 lb. guy, two smaller versions of Edge, and Edge himself, a 9-time World Champion that has beaten the likes of Mick Foley, John Cena, The Undertaker, Batista, and Jeff Hardy? No.
 
justinsayne said:
And Raven can whack Edge in the head with a steel chair as he's running to hit the spear, not to metion I'm not so sure Edge will be able to stand by that point in the match, ya know losing all that blood and all

Raven doesn't even need to use the chair. What the best way to counter a guy whose finisher is a head first dive into you? Why, with a guy who has one of the three best DDT's in the business, THAT'S HOW!

So forget the chair - Edge goes for the spear, and Raven quickly counters with the Raven Effect DDT for the win. For fun, the DDT is onto a barbed wire flaming table for all you hardcorists out there. Afterwards, Raven goes to ringside and slips into his Johnny Polo gimmick and proceeeds to also call a better match than any other announcers.
 
Edge has accomplished more and has defeated the much better competition of the two. I'm a huge Raven fan. If this were a popularity contest I'd vote for Raven in a heartbeat and I'd continue to vote for him over just about anyone. The problem is, this isn't a popularity contest. People want to keep bringing up the hardcore rules, like Edge has never wrestled under hardcore rules or in gimmick matches. The truth is Edge has been in countless gimmick matches and has an extremely good record in these matches. He probably has a higher win % in these matches than Raven does and he's faced better competition, so that whole argument that Raven would definitely win, because of the hardcore rules should go out the window.

The fact is Edge has won over 27 titles in his professional career. He's accomplished literally everything there is to accomplish in the WWE and than some. He takes this match, because kayfabe wise he's the better wrestler and has defeated much better kayfabe wrestlers.
 
At the apex of Edge's career, he has Chavo Guerrero, Bam Neely, and the Edge-heads to fight for him as well. Do any of you actually think that Raven (who in his prime had no one but himself) can overcome a former E.C.W. champion, a 6'9 280 lb. guy, two smaller versions of Edge, and Edge himself, a 9-time World Champion that has beaten the likes of Mick Foley, John Cena, The Undertaker, Batista, and Jeff Hardy? No.

You know nothing about Raven's career do you, Raven has been the leader of many many different stables, in ECW he had Raven's Nest, in WCW he had The Flock and The Dead Pool, and in TNA he had The Gathering and Serotonin, pick which ever one you want, anyone of them will counter the nobodies that made up La Familia
 
But Raven isn't that good. He was just the best out of a bunch of guys who never really did anything in their careers.

You mean guys like Terry Gordy, Dr. Death Steve Williams, Terry Funk, Steve Austin, Rey Mysterio, The Dudleys, Chris Benoit, Eddie Guerrero, Jushin "thunder" Liger, Dean Malenko, Bam Bam Bigelow, Lance Storm, and RVD, yeah sounds like a bunch of guys who really did nothing with their careers to me:rolleyes:

And he didn't win titleS in WWE.

He's a 27 time Hardcore champion, which is the same amount of titles that Edge has won in WWE

The only title he won was the hardcore title, and the WWE hardcore title was the biggest joke I've ever seen.

Just because you think it was a joke doesn't mean it was still a recognized title in WWE, and one Raven won 27 times and Edge won 0 times

When he won the heavyweight title in TNA it was during a time when guys like Sean Waltman were competing for the title. Even Ron Killings held the title during this time frame.

It's still goes down in the history books as a Heavyweight title for the second biggest promotion in wrestling today

The fact is Edge has won over 27 titles in his professional career.

and Raven has won 37 titles in his career, and that's only counting his time in WWE, WCW, ECW, & TNA

He's accomplished literally everything there is to accomplish in the WWE and than some.

How is being the biggest fluke champion in the history of WWE a GOOD accomplishment

He takes this match, because kayfabe wise he's the better wrestler and has defeated much better kayfabe wrestlers.

Kayfabe wise Raven bleeds Edge dry, Raven wins
 
Or maybe it was because he was really just that danm good, trying to bury and entire company the guy was successful in is just a cheap move Will, I expect better from you, especially since knowing you you prolly have loads of ECW tapes in that massive cabinet thing you say you have

I'm not taking any credit away from E.C.W at all. I loved watching the senseless and mindless violence that was a bingo hall show. And that's not a cheap shot, it's the truth. But face facts.. Steve Corino, Justin Credible, Lance Storm, Jerry Lynn and a handful of others were the "Wrestling workers" in a Company otherwise filled with drunks, drug addicts and guys who couldn't make it anywhere else.

Raven't character fit him, but not because he's so amazing.. it's because the alternative.. well.. was this..

14.jpg

No wonder he turned to drugs, and started quoting famous poets. He likely had a hard time trying to figure out if he was a Male or Female after that gimmick fucked his head up.

All of that still doesn't change the fact, Edge is better in-ring than Raven is. And hardcore or not.. it isn't like Edge doesn't know his way around a table, ladder or steal chair. Advantage.. Edge.

I already countered this argument, perhpas you should go back and read some more posts before you start spewig the same horseshit as all the other Edgeheads, he's beaten the likes of Terry Gordy & Dr. Death Steve Williams, two guys that are legends in this business, as well as taking Terry Funk to the limit, and nearly beating him(in a match that was far more brutal than the WM Hardcore match w/ Foley), the only reason he lost that match was do to outside interference by Dreamer

The two note-worthy things here, are who he's defeated and almost defeated.

Terry Gordy, a guy who's career hit it's peak in the early 80's.. and didn't fall to Raven until the mid 90's. Nice victory.. tell me, did Raven beat him with an Evenflow, or did Father time put in an assist on this one?

Steve Williams, once again a guy who's prime came about a decade (plus) sooner than his match w/ Raven. But let's not over-shadow the fact that the victory you're likely referring to, was also moments after Williams defeated Axel Rotten - then got sucked into an impromptu match against Raven, then lost.

Terry Funk, yet another Legend, yet another decade (plus) beyond his prime.. and this time, Raven couldn't even defeat him. Oh, but it's okay because Dreamer was to blame. SO, Funk (a 50 yr old man, if not older) held out so long, through all the hardcore violence and punishment that you and all these other mindless E.C.W nuts claim Raven dishes out with the best of them.. only to wait until the final moments before losing.. so Dreamer can save him, and help the old timer find a victory.

SO.. let's recap. Raven knows how to defeat has-beens that you refer to as Legends. Okay.. how does any of that, help against a guy that'd be roughly around the same age, if not younger.. in better physical condition than any of the above mentioned names when Raven faced them, and know his way around a ring including how to handle weapons more so than the above names, w/ exception to maybe Funk.

Advantage.. Edge.

Because IT SHOWS HIS TOUGHNESS, AND THAT HE IS ABLE TO WITHSTAND FAR MORE PUNISHMENT THAN SOMEONE LIKE EDGE

Edge has shown toughness before. He's gutted it out in T.L.C matches, Hell in a Cell matches, Cage matches, and almost any other type of match W.W.E's been willing to put on.

Raven might hold a better threshold for punishment, but that only serves Edge more.. because Edge likes dishing it out. And being the Opportunistic individual he is, it's not like Edge is going to stand in place and wait for Raven to inflict pain on him, unlike Raven, who often gets over confident and allows his opponents to inflict massive amounts of pain on him instantly.. to show some type of mental toughness.

Once again, Edge being the opportunist that he is, with Raven being the sadist that he is.. this is yet another advantage that falls in Edge's court, as he's more than willing to give Raven a Christmas package full of gifts. By Christmas, I mean joyful and by gifts, I mean pain.

Advantage.. Edge.

Oh please Will, you and I both know he dealt with very little barbwire in that match, Raven has survived much much more pain, suffering, and blood loss than Edge could ever dream of, Edge took out a broken down Foley, the guy was only a shell of his former self, and it took everything Edge had to beat him, Raven is far more sick and twisted, he's far more calculating in how he uses his tools of pain than a semi-retired Foley is

I could easily refer you back to the Terry Funk match, in which a guy in his Prime.. Raven.. couldn't even defeat a 50+ year old man, Funk.. and yes, Dreamer played a part.. but a win is a win, and a loss is what Raven took.

The point the hardcore match at Mania showed, was Edge can hang with the Land of extreme.. and not just his Mania match, but the One Night Stand showdown as well. While the opportunistic side of Edge took full advantage and pinned the Woman.. the fact is, earlier in the contest it was Edge's abilities that played the role in helping get Funk & Dreamer out of the picture long enough to do so.

Edge isn't the ultimate opportunists he's more like the ultimate pussy, if anything he just gets lucky, the big reason for most of his success on SD! was due to him fucking the GM, pretty sure he won't be able to do the same with Heyman...or at least I hope not

Geez, do you not understand characters or anything? It was in his character to not use all the skills he has available to win. Thus is what a great heel does. He makes other people win for him. But when he needs to, he wins on his own.

Wow, name calling? :rolleyes: That's sure to gain votes.

So he storyline fucked a GM to gain 3 Championships.. that's 3 more W.W.E Heavyweight Championships than Raven's ever sniffed. And believe me, Raven.. would've fucked Vickie had he of been given the opportunity as well. Raven would've fucked Chavo, if he felt it'd help his career.

Kinda countered your own argument there, good job

Actually, I proved my point. Edge defeated greats like Taker, Cena, Shawn Michaels & Triple H. By himself, or with the help of others. He still holds victories over top Superstars. Whereas Raven can't say the same, even with all the help Raven's had by surrounding himself with "flocks" of people to aid him against the likes of the Sandman and Tommy Dreamer.

When the hell has Edge ever beaten Triple H?

He's defeated Triple H a couple different times through Tag matches, and in set-up matches on television shows building up to Pay per views in which they've been involved in matches against.

Go back to the DX/Rated RKO days. Jump back to the build-up to the Triple Threat going into Backlash w/ H.H.H, Edge & Cena. It's happened.

None of which compare to the level of violence he would face in a match with Raven in ECW

Meh. E.C.W violence is touch and go. You could have one of the most sadistic, brutal and barbaric matches known to man.. or you could have one of the most boring, overrated, flat-crowd pieces of shit a Company's ever tried selling you.

Many know how to reverse it and yet Raven still hits it on them, not too mention Raven doesn't useally go for this move until the end of that match after his oppeant has been beaten down and has lost several pints of blood

Again, you say this as if Raven wouldn't be worn down in his own right. Please, Raven isn't some unbeatable super-power. He's a fucking mid-carder, that was great in this type of match.. but still lost very much so.

And Raven can whack Edge in the head with a steel chair as he's running to hit the spear, not to metion I'm not so sure Edge will be able to stand by that point in the match, ya know losing all that blood and all

Edge wouldn't let the match get that far. Ya know, being an Ultimate Opportunist and all. :rolleyes: (See how you can make things seem one sided and unrealistic - I can do)

Yes exactly Will, YOU should think before you vote, don't let your blind love affair for Edge make your decision for you

I wasn't. I was voting for which Superstar has the better overall talent and natural ability to win this match. It's the guy who's overcome anything set in his path.. not the guy who's made it big, off beating has-beens, drunks and bar mice.

EDGE WINS!

LOL, this statement makes me laugh. So because the WWE puts the title on Edge 9 times in 3 years, he's suddenly a Legend? What a joke. He's won the belt 9 times, and barely has a full year worth of total days as champion under his belt. Just because Edge is so terrible he loses the belt all the time, doesn't make him a legend.

No, defeating guy's like John Cena, Triple H, the Undertaker, and Shawn Michaels all in-route to becoming a Nine Time World Heavyweight Champion.. make him a Legend.. in the making.

And he isn't terrible at losing Championships, he's doing what you claim (later below) he can't.. that's playing his character, to perfection.

So? The fact of the matter is that not only was he successful in ECW, he was also successful in WCW, he won titles in WWE, and he was a World Heavyweight champion in TNA.

Raven won the United States Championship in W.C.W, then lost it a day later. He held the Tag titles for a month, if that, then disappeared. He won the T.N.A Heavyweight title, only to drop it at a house show less than a month later.

You go on about Edge being terrible at losing things, look at Raven's track record. At least the titles Edge's lost were big enough to warrant having constant pressure. Raven couldn't even hold onto a decent mid-card reign.

Calling Raven a career nobody is absurd.

Raven wasn't and is NOT a no body.. but to say he's better than Edge, is absurd and foolish.

The fact of the matter is this. On what basis, aside from the fact that Edge seems to lose title matches quite often, can you vote for Edge over Raven? Edge doesn't play his character as well, he's not as good in the ring, he is comparable on the mic (maybe), and he's no where near as interesting. Don't get me wrong, I can't stand ECW, but saying that Edge is better because he is horrible in title matches is just a silly argument. The only reason Edge is in the main-event is because the WWE put ALL of their creative energies into Edge. They pushed him and pushed him and pushed him to become a main-eventer, and he failed over and over and over again. It wasn't until they finally had John Cena make him look good was Edge finally able to be considered a legit main-eventer. With the type of support and backing the WWE gave Edge, Raven could have been a 9 time World Champion too.

Seriously? Wow, relating Edge's success all the way back to John Cena. Really, Sly, really? You know.. I found a sign the other day.. didn't quite know who it'd fit with.. but this statement alone just made me realize it's perfect for you.

aac.jpg


If it doesn't relate to John Cena, you just talk enough random crap to make people think you know what you have a clue about.

Edge's success came off a random event that wasn't in all honesty ever meant to happen. That of fucking Amy Dumas. Now, does that make Edge a fluke? NO.. it makes him lucky to have fallen into that hole. (no pun intended) But it certainly doesn't make him a fluke. He took what he had, and what people put on him.. and he ran with it, and turned it into something a whole lot more.

Nine Championships later, and one of the greatest heels in the industry.. Edge should be blowing Raven out in this contest.. instead, because so many mindless E.C.W fanatics think hardcore = victory every time.. it's a close race.

Raven has better mic skills, "I" will even admit that. I loved Raven for his promos, but that's it. His wrestling ability doesn't compare to Edge, and at most Raven and Edge are tied if not putting Edge over Raven, in the books of strategy. Both men will look for every opening they can take, the difference is Edge has made a Legendary career out of opportunistic openings.. Raven has only ever gotten lucky, at best.

Raven doesn't even need to use the chair. What the best way to counter a guy whose finisher is a head first dive into you? Why, with a guy who has one of the three best DDT's in the business, THAT'S HOW!

So forget the chair - Edge goes for the spear, and Raven quickly counters with the Raven Effect DDT for the win. For fun, the DDT is onto a barbed wire flaming table for all you hardcorists out there. Afterwards, Raven goes to ringside and slips into his Johnny Polo gimmick and proceeeds to also call a better match than any other announcers.

He might as well get a head-start now, because Raven winning this match is something that should never even be a thought.. much less a possibility.

VOTE EDGE
 
I have to give this one to Edge and here's why:
Edge can come out of nowhere and win at any time, but so can Raven. While Raven may be more experienced with weapons, Edge beat Mick Foley (The HARDCORE LEGEND) in a hardcore match at the biggest PPV of the year. So I'd say they're dead even. The thing that gives it to Edge is the crowd. I know that Raven has the ECW advantage and if this match took place anywhere else but Toronto, I'd give it to Raven. The fact of the matter is that in any ECW match, the crowd would boo the holy hell out of Edge. But since this match is in Toronto, the crowd would definately be backing Edge. I think this would throw Raven off. He'd be too concerned about playing to the crowd for "turning on him" in this instance that Edge would be able to capitalize. By far the best match of the tournament, but I have to give the win to Edge. Maybe a quick roll up or a reversal into a pin, but Edge just barely makes it out alive
 
You mean guys like Terry Gordy, Dr. Death Steve Williams, Terry Funk, Steve Austin, Rey Mysterio, The Dudleys, Chris Benoit, Eddie Guerrero, Jushin "thunder" Liger, Dean Malenko, Bam Bam Bigelow, Lance Storm, and RVD, yeah sounds like a bunch of guys who really did nothing with their careers to me

Almost none of those guys were in ECW at the time Raven was there main eventing. Not only that but of the guys you have listed Raven has beaten only two of them and I think he only faced three of them well he was in ECW. And the two that he did beat, Gordy and Steve Williams, are probably the worst of the guys on that list.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
174,846
Messages
3,300,837
Members
21,727
Latest member
alvarosamaniego
Back
Top