Lord Sidious said:
I stand by the fact that Rapper John Cena, given the same monster push he receives today, would actually be a Pop Culture icon in this day and age. He would unquestionably draw a Hell of a lot more, with an edgy character, than he does in his "goody two shoes" one.
How so? I really think the appeal of hip-hop and the culture connected to it is overrated. It's a niche that has reared it's ugly head into the main stream, but it's not something I define as THE main stream or as icon-making. I think with the rapper gimmick, Cena would be exactly where he is now because there would probably be that rap-hating segment of the audience also booing him and wishing he'd go away.
How so? I really think the appeal of hip-hop and the culture connected to it is overrated. It's a niche that has reared it's ugly head into the main stream, but it's not something I define as THE main stream or as icon-making. I think with the rapper gimmick, Cena would be exactly where he is now because there would probably be that rap-hating segment of the audience also booing him and wishing he'd go away.
I didn't hear too many people booing Cena when he was billed a Face with the Rapper gimmick.
But this was John Cena's niche, that differentiated him from all the other marquee names in WWE in the past. And they essentially threw it all away.
Hulk Hogan was the All-American Goodie 2 Shoes Goody Guy that trained, said his prayers, and ate his vitamins. It was a gimmick that worked exceptionally well for its time.
Steve Austin was the rogue, Anti-Establishment, loner, Anti-Hero of the WWE who was exactly what the WWE Fanbase was looking for during the time of the Attitude Era. It was cool to cheer on the "bad guys" during this time frame, so the gimmick worked exceptionally well.
The Rock was the most electrifying man in sports entertainment. Exceptionally talented and brought an audience to life like no other could. Wisecracking, Witty, Cocky, Suave, and Cool.
John Cena is .... what exactly? Is he a marine? What is his gimmick? Is he the Hulk Hogan of this day and age, goody two-shoes babyface? That is what I feel they try to market him as, but it is not as successful as it could be because of the day and age we live in.
Hulk Hogan himself would not have worked in this day and age, if he was just starting out and making a name for himself. He is however, still the most over talent that still gets the largest pop of anyone because of nostalgia from the wrestling fans, who are appreciative of the impact he had on people's childhoods. But he wouldn't work in this day and age if this were his prime, as evidenced by John Cena.
I think there still needs to be a degree of rogue in today's Top Babyface. Where as they don't necessarily need to be out drinking beer and giving people the middle finger every show ... I do feel they still need somewhat of a loner, anti-establishment persona about them.
Rapper John Cena worked, because he was that loner, and he was out for himself, where as he is nothing more than a Pro-Establishment, Pro-WWE player in this day and age.
Cena got tremendous reactions as the Rapper, and no I don't think the hip-hop culture is necessarily over-rated. You may not like hardcore rap music. I actually despise it, myself. But that doesn't mean that I am going to let my distaste for rap music get in the way of an awesome character.
Take a look at the pops Cena received as the Rapper, and how he had the crowd in the palm of his hand. He was remarkable ...
John Cena vs Vince McMahon
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vDDEfARLwmQ
John Cena va Kenzo Suzuki
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PU3KuYLl9vg
John Cena vs Big Show
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=40ukN7Qpnsw
John Cena vs Brock Lesnar
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AEvxqKPTC2Q
This one is actually one of my favorites, because it actually occurred on Sunday Night Heat before a PPV. And I truly believe that Cena didn't spend a large time memorizing this bit just for Heat. I think the stuff just rolls off his tongue, which is extremely, extremely impressive.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tLzgC0NL11k
Rapper John Cena, given the same push he has today, would be getting much better reactions and have a much larger following, instead of being the goody, two-shoes Face, in my view. He was edgy, witty, a loner, spoke his mind, wasn't afraid to use coarse language to make his point, and could definitely be construed as somewhat of a pop culture icon. Can you actually refer to John Cena as a pop culture icon today? Hardly.