As I only bought SvR2008 more or less recently when it came on Platinum hereabouts, I can only say that I have little more than a glimmer of hope for the 2009 version. SvR 2008 was easily the worst Smackdown ever... and I agree with what someone said, the series has been going downhill ever since they changed the title to Smackdon vs Raw... Here Comes The Pain was plain awesomeness, with a huge roster, many matches, for the time great graphics, extensive backstage areas, new move animations and grapple systems and so on and so forth...
Fastforward to (meanwhile) 2008: In this game of utter crapness, not only did they leave out what seems like half the WWE roster; it also seems like one half of the roster that's actually in the game isn't with WWE anymore either, including some core players (Booker T, Bobby Lashley). Agreed, this has been the case with v2007 as well, and even though Kurt Angle leaving WWE probably hurt them a lot more than Booker and Lashley, it somehow didn't seem as bad to me as this year's installment does. Anyway, then they have more glitches in the game than ever before, terrible clipping issues (goddamit can somebody PLEASE finally fix that damn Back Superplex where the opponent seams to float down to the mat like a metre away from the executing superstar), weapons you can hardly move around once they're lying on the mat and the worst commentary in forever, considering the fact how the commentators just break off in midsentence when you executed a "power" move, instead of just finishing the one sentence and THEN commencing the next. And what I particularly hate about them is how they keep on talking about "how great this match is and we don't know which way it's going" even after you've already scored a pinfall or submission and the bell is rung. Argh...
And the list just goes on, the worst features probably being the drastic reduction of grapple moves for each character... I mean, come on - last year, everyone had 4 sets á 4 moves each for grapples (Clean/Dirty, Submission, and 2 more to be selected freely), and this year they for some reason have to put those Ultimate Control grapples (which in my opinion worked perfectly with clicking on the right stick in SvR2007) on two of those 4 grapple moves, leaving each wrestler with only 2 sets á 4 moves of regular grapple moves. WTF?!?! I thought including that grapple system was the best thing that happened with Here Comes The Pain, and they had been improving at least this one pretty much every year, and now THIS?! They REDUCE your basic move arsenal?! And then that ultimate no-go... the way you just can't switch from one opponent to the other (or can you somehow and I'm just too stupid to figure it out?); that makes any match type with more than one opponent essentially unplayable imho. Bleh, terrible, terrible stuff.
And once again they cut back on the backstage areas. Why can't we get some of the freely accessible ones again like in HCTP?! It's just that much cooler to walk from one Backstage area to the next and use everything as a weapon on the way, instead of being limited to that one small parking lot with only those ultimate grapple spots to be used?!
The 24/7 mode is kind of too long winded for me, as the storylines quickly repeat themselves and you always get the same pre- and post-match cutscenes, which do not even have anything to do with the storylines or match outcomes most of the times (I just hate it when I just destroyed my opponent, but in the next cutscene my wrestler rolls out of the ring in agony while my supposedly crushed opponent celebrates in the ring... stupid). And the list just goes on and on.
The only good thing about SvR was the use of your own music for theme songs, that is awesome indeed.
Now I really hope SvsR 2009 will be better - if only a little. But I agree - I don't think we need an Inferno Match. Just give me a Falls Count Anywhere with decent Backstage areas. I hope they include some DLC (wrestlers, moves, arenas, whatever) this time, and maybe the roster will remain halfway stable until the thing comes out in winter lol. But I just don't see it happening... Unless they really completely revamp the game engine at some point, the series will probably continue the decline WWE had been on the past few years. But seeing as WWE is trying to pick up the pace these days again, I just hope THQ makes use of that.
However, what do you guys think - I believe THQ's WWE license will run out by 2010; who do you think will make WWE games then, and what do you expect?
I mean, I still remember when everyone was so hyped about Acclaim's WWF Attitude back in the day, and looking back now, that game was really bad lol. Unfortunately, I think that THQ was the only publisher ever to put out worthwhile Wrestling games (thinking back to No Mercy, Here Comes The Pain as prime examples); agreed, they also put out some crap (WCW Nitro/Thunder for PSOne, Wrestlemania 21 for XBOX), but EA just completely screwed up with their WCW license back with WCW Mayhem for PSOne as well, Acclaim's (I believe?) Legends of Wrestling wasn't good either... and I'm personally not really familiar with many japanese Wrestling games (at least I haven't yet heard about THE ONE ultimate wrestling game from there), aside from the Fire Pro Series which I absolutely love - but that doesn't count since it's 2D and we really should have a contemporary looking wrestling franchise, heh.
TNA Impact should be interesting though, I will definitely get this game just to see what Midway does.