IrishCanadian25
Going on 10 years with WrestleZone
I was expecting certain people to come and weight in here, Skullz wasn't one of them. I am pleasantly surprised, and this rings of a good debate.
You make a strong point, but I don't think you can base a vote for Andre in THIS round based off of what "may happen" next round. We're not trying to book a good tournament, we're trying to settle who is the best of all time based on who would realisitcally win in these situations. I think Andre in his prime (mid 70's Japan and early WWF) would take out HHH in his prime ('97-2000) in a great match.
Much the way I feel about Yokozuna vs Undertaker, I also feel about a potential Andre vs HBK match. It would depend largely on the stipulation. And while HHH vs HBK is a FAR move even encounter, I think Andre vs HBK is far more polarizing, pitting two TOTALLY different styles from two TOTALLY different eras against one another. Wrestlemania 6 was the only time these two appeared on the same WM card, no?
Anyway, I feel a vote for Andre is justified and that he'd also have a good shot, depending on stipulation, of going over HBK as well. But we won't know without YOUR vote, people!
You make a strong point, but I don't think you can base a vote for Andre in THIS round based off of what "may happen" next round. We're not trying to book a good tournament, we're trying to settle who is the best of all time based on who would realisitcally win in these situations. I think Andre in his prime (mid 70's Japan and early WWF) would take out HHH in his prime ('97-2000) in a great match.
Much the way I feel about Yokozuna vs Undertaker, I also feel about a potential Andre vs HBK match. It would depend largely on the stipulation. And while HHH vs HBK is a FAR move even encounter, I think Andre vs HBK is far more polarizing, pitting two TOTALLY different styles from two TOTALLY different eras against one another. Wrestlemania 6 was the only time these two appeared on the same WM card, no?
Anyway, I feel a vote for Andre is justified and that he'd also have a good shot, depending on stipulation, of going over HBK as well. But we won't know without YOUR vote, people!