Round 1, Day 7, Edmonton, AL

[Shocky]

#2 The Crippler Chris Benoit vs. #63 Little Guido/Nunzio​

The following match takes place in Los Angeles, CA under normal WWE Rules. Debate and follow the rules, no spamming please.

1. Not a popularity contest.
2. Will rules of a region come into play
3. Will crowd be a factor.
4. Watch the Benoit bitching with this match.

 

[Shocky]

#31 Badass Billy Gunn vs. #34 The Godfather​

The following match takes place in Los Angeles, CA under normal WWE Rules. Debate and follow the rules, no spamming please.

1. Not a popularity contest.
2. Will rules of a region come into play
3. Will crowd be a factor.

 

[Shocky]

#15 The Next Big Thing Brock Lesnar vs. #50 Kaz Hayashi​

The following match takes place in Los Angeles, CA under normal WWE Rules. Debate and follow the rules, no spamming please.

1. Not a popularity contest.
2. Will rules of a region come into play
3. Will crowd be a factor.

 

[Shocky]

#18 Big Sexy Kevin Nash vs. #47 Super Nova​

The following match takes place in Los Angeles, CA under normal WWE Rules. Debate and follow the rules, no spamming please.

1. Not a popularity contest.
2. Will rules of a region come into play
3. Will crowd be a factor.

 

[Shocky]

#7 The Fallen Angel Christopher Daniels vs. #58 Scrap Iron Adam Pearce​

The following match takes place in Los Angeles, CA under normal WWE Rules. Debate and follow the rules, no spamming please.

1. Not a popularity contest.
2. Will rules of a region come into play
3. Will crowd be a factor.

 

[Shocky]

#26 Carlito vs. #39 La Parka​

The following match takes place in Los Angeles, CA under normal WWE Rules. Debate and follow the rules, no spamming please.

1. Not a popularity contest.
2. Will rules of a region come into play
3. Will crowd be a factor.

 

[Shocky]

#10 The Loose Cannon Brian Pillman vs. #55 Shannon Moore​

The following match takes place in Los Angeles, CA under normal WWE Rules. Debate and follow the rules, no spamming please.

1. Not a popularity contest.
2. Will rules of a region come into play
3. Will crowd be a factor.

 

[Shocky]

#23 The World's Most Dangerous Man Ken Shamrock vs. the Dog Faced Gremlin Rick Steiner​

The following match takes place in Los Angeles, CA under normal WWE Rules. Debate and follow the rules, no spamming please.

1. Not a popularity contest.
2. Will rules of a region come into play
3. Will crowd be a factor.

 

[Y 2 Jake]

Rick Steiner was never the wrestler his brother was. By the time The Steiners were popular he was already nearly past his prime. Scott was the worker that made that team great.

I always thought that WWE missed out with Shamrock. He was always over, even though he was pretty bland. He was also pretty solid. I don't think he'd be a wrestler who'd have great matches. Byt he'd consistently have good matches.

 

[Y 2 Jake]

If you're basing your vote on Shannon Moore vs. Loose Cannon Brian Pillman, then Moore wins. If it's based on Flyin' Brian then there is no other option. Flyin' Brian was awesome. Shame people remember the gimmick more than the wrestler he used to be.

 

[Y 2 Jake]

How the fuck can people vote for Carlito? He sucks. No good matches. Apparently he's charismatic. What? Like Jeff Hardy is the Charismatic Enigma. Do WWE or Jim Ross know what charisma is? He's testicles. He doesn't even have potential. When Carlito ''takes to the air'' it takes him 10 seconds longer than anyone else. He jumps up and you wonder, will gravity bring him down. It's touch and go when he trys a high risk move.

 

[Y 2 Jake]

I think Daniels is awesome. Problem is that he's a career mid carder. So yeah he is overrated. But He'll be one of those wrestlers that will still be one of the best workers around when he's in his 50's. I see him as a similar wrestler to Finlay in that respect.

 

[Y 2 Jake]

Nash has only evenr had good matches with Bret Hart & HBK. Other than that, if they've been good it's a fluke. He's crap. A push based on size. Nova on the other hand was excellent. There was a reason he was given the Simon Dean gimmick. With his look he was enver going to be a superstar in WWE. But he was there to teach younger wrestlers how to be great.

 

[Y 2 Jake]

Hayashi over Lesnar any day. What it comes down to is that one has been wrestling for years and is proven. The other, while grreat wrestled on a main roster for two years. There's no comparison really.

 

[Y 2 Jake]

What's will all the Billy Gunn votes? He's shit. Some people believe the whole J.R. ''best pure athlete'' shit. I'm not saying The Godfather was much better in the ring. But at least he was entertaining, he always got a crowd reaction. Coupled with the fact he's had not one, but two awesome gimmicks. Pimp & Papa Shango.

 

[Y 2 Jake]

Benoit should win the whole thing. His whole style is based of the best wrestler of all time. And he's a big WWE name. Also coupled with the fact he's also one of wrestlings biggest names ever now. His competition is probably HBK & Angle. Ok so he doesn't have the charisma of both. But he's certainly equal on wrestling skills. And outside of wrestling more people have heard of Benoit than they have of the other two.

 

[Mighty NorCal]

Benoit, easily. Nunzio is nothing more than a jobber, for at least the last three or four years. Benoit on the other hand, is one of the all time greatest, if not the greatest ever. Great selling, great intensity, could work with just about anyone. didnt have great charisma. fuck charisma. at least when it comes to chris benoit.

 

[Mighty NorCal]

goodness, why dont you just ask me if I want a turd sandwhich or turd soup? Both were trash in the ring. But godfather had great charisma, and played some fuckin fantastic, if not utterly ridiculous characters. Gunn on the other hand, couldnt even get over in a feud Vs THE ROCK, and after being in NAO in DX....for fuuuuuucks sakes...

 

[Mighty NorCal]

how the FUCK is carlito winning this over fucking La Parka???? have any of you EVER seen WCW saturday night??? La Parka was fuckin awesome, and had bitchin charisma, and was a damn master of the high flying moves. La Parka was absurdly entertaining. Carlito, at one time was decent, but he just absolutely sucks, and has sucked, for the better part of two years now. Carlito is ass. La Parka is awesome. THIS is a travesty...

 

[Mighty NorCal]

Flyin Brian was DAMN good, and one of my first favorites when I first took to wrestling. Great seller, and very athletic. Im really high on shannon Moore, but Pillman was DAMN good in his day. Check out his WCW stuff for any proof you need. Pillman for sure

 

[HBK-aholic]

Benoit definately. His style was great, and he will certainly go down as one of the best. I hate everything that happened with his death because it means eveything he did before that will have just gone. And I know what happened was an awful thing and he definately deserves to be reprimanded for it, but I think it's sad that's all he's going to be known for from now on.

His ability was second to very few people. He has little competition in the whole thing, and people knew when watching Benoit they were watching a good 'un.

 

[HBK-aholic]

I was never a WCW fan so I suppose I have to give my vote to Carlito. WCW never entertained me.

However, I've never thought Carlito was awful, but when you watch him on TV sometimes it sure as hell seems that way. However seeing him live I always enjoy. He is great. He works for everyone in that damn arena, and even though his matches are usually at the beginning, he still has almost every person in that arena hooked.

 

[Mighty NorCal]

I really think WWE missed the boat with shamrock, very much. How they managed to fuck up with him is beyond me. It makes me wonder how he could one of those guys that I can sit back and say "what the fuck ever happened to that guy" and honestly not be able to remember. Wasnt he the fuckin "most dangerous man in the world??"...an amazing, respected, UFC fighter?? what the fuck, really....

Rick, on the other hand was never really that great, and was never even close to his brother. at least in the early years I mean. Shamrock for sure.

 

[Shadowmancer]

Resultsare Here

It doesn't matter who's rule we are officially using here we are using Brian Fuckin Pillman's rules. His matches with Liger and as a Member of the Hollywood blondes are legendary. Have Brian Pillman before Car Accident add Loose Cannon and we have a perfect wrestler. Pillman came the closest to the combination anyone has ever gotten, that is including guys like HBK and Bret Hart.

 

[X]

I'm a Ken Shamrock mark. I'll admit it. I was young, and he was a badass legit.

Rick Steiner isn't as bad as some people think, but he's not much better then good.

Shamrock on the other hand atleast knew his stuff, could do some mean suplexes, great submissions, and a style of tenacity that really made him perfect to get over for the crowd. As long as he stayed away from a microphone. He was terrible on the mic, terrible.

Shamrock fo' sho.