Now, all this ballyhoo over the ECW Invasion. Was it as good as people had made it out to be? Yes and no. I personally liked it better than the Nexus invasion. First off, security and the "boys in the back" tried to stop this invasion. That was the MAJOR plot hole in the events of last month with regards to Nexus. Were the boys in the back really that inept not to do something? And I have a hard time believing that security in the arena could be that inept either. I know someone out there is saying "it's all part of the show," but it was WWE's attempt to be "real." And if you are going to attempt to be real, you have to cover all the plot holes. Secondly, there is an advantage to having established wrestlers being the invading force compared to having, to paraphrase Classy Freddie Blassie, eight "pencil necked geeks" jump a barricade and invade. People know these wrestlers, and as such, they've already drawn a connection to them. Third, this goes towards something that was already established instead of just shock value. The ECW guys have been sitting in the audience for a long time, biding their time until this moment. The Nexus thing was so out of the dark that when it happened, it caused a hooplah and has somewhat become monotonous afterward. (Other things have killed that storyline for me, but I'll save that for later.) Also, one has to wonder: IS this the they Abyss has been talking about, or is there yet another group waiting in the wings to take TNA over?
I think you missed some logic with the Nexus angle, while comparing it to this week's ECW angle on Impact, that I feel the need to point out. The Nexus aren’t just random people who came out of the crowd and aren’t even with the company, they were shown for months on WWE television and clearly had been working with the WWE for months. Wade Barrett had won a WWE contract so him appearing on screen made perfect sense. It actually makes less sense if the whole invasion of Nexus into the main event match was real to say that the whole roster of RAW would rush out and attack these rogue wrestlers. That would be a danger to talent and officials and security wouldn’t have allowed that to happen in a real life situation because it would’ve escalated the situation that much worse for them. Also, realistically, most of the roster and officials backstage would be scramblers to figure out what was actually going on before rushing to do anything.
It also 'logically' doesn’t make sense for a program that’s happening live for them to send out their officials and security to get into a physical altercation with wrestlers who are basically working for the company. That’s not something they’d want to show on their television and it’s entirely feasible that a company would let the wrestlers lash out until the show went off the air before security took over. Look at the Bret Hart Survivor Series incident; they let him trash everything just like the Nexus did and didn’t stop him because it was real and instead they wanted to avoid physical confrontations that could’ve brought about lawsuits and all sorts of things, including things getting really out of hand.
It’s actually entirely unrealistic and ridiculous to think that in a real situation officials and security are going to rush down the ring on live television (or taped as TNA was), get in the ring, and get into a brawl with the ECW invaders. Even more unrealistic that TNA officials are going to allow their wrestlers to run down and get into a brawl with people and endanger themselves with something that wasn’t “suppose” to be planned.
Secondly, you’ve also seemingly missed the fact that the Nexus didn’t just come out of nowhere. The Nexus angle was developed for months on the Nxt show, and the pieces leading up to the invasion on RAW can clearly be seen through the entire first season of Next. That makes it far better thought out and built up then the ECW invasion where they just randomly had these guys sitting in the crowd for weeks. And also, even if the Nexus are “rookies” they’re still just as relevant and credible as the ECW wrestlers who haven’t been stars for ten years but have been on the same level as the Nexus in recent years (because each one of them have been nothing but the lowest level of the roster in recent memory). At least WWE is pushing younger talent with their angle instead of old talent who aren’t relevant anymore. They’re also not pretending their invading talent are stars when they’re clearly not, which TNA is doing.
But in truth the Nexus and ECW Invasion angles aren’t even comparable, so I don’t see why people are even attempting to do so. Hopefully this ECW thing is just leading up to a single PPV send off and isn’t an ongoing angle to any degree, otherwise it doesn’t look very promising.