I think with Eddie it was a case of throwing something against a wall to see if it stuck. he was over, but I don't think it was over enough to validate the world title going on him. Show I simply can't see getting the belt as he was just too out of shape for it. Angle...maybe, but like I said I hink they wanted to try something new. I still don't think he would have gotten it without Lesnar leaving as Lesnar was a surefire champion already.
As for Eddie and JBL, the problem wasn't all Eddie's. The problem partially was that he had zero heat and no one bought him as credible so the crowd sucked the life out of it and the guys didn't know how to react to that, which is understandble as it would rattle anyone. Also the bullrope match was just a bad choice for a gimmick. It's like the table match where you don't have to actually do anything yet you can change the title anyway. Bradshaw needed to get a clean pin and never did that, which made him seem more illegimate which angered the fans even more. The JD match isn't bad, but it's far from great.
Also, quite a few of those were embelished things in there. I'm not that extreme against Eddie, but he's far from a master like so many people say.