i think we all need to understand that once your in the heavyweight division theres no splitting hairs. Theres a huge difference between a heavyweight fighting a super heavyweight as opposed to a crusierweight OR a light-heavyweight. taking on a heavyweight..
theres actually no comparisons that work with other sports. Again the closest is COLLEGIATE WRESTLING because it relies more on brute strength and grappling as well as holds.
IN BOXING CM Punk would be able to compensate with speed and punches aimed directly at the holes in his opponent's defense.
In kickboxing punk could rely on swift kicks to weak points in his opponents leg joints then work his way up. He still has the HEIGHT to make his way up his opponents body and in boxing he would be able to get good shots in because of the reach a 6'1 man usually has assuming thats his real height..
in MMA he might be able to use some of the moves Royce Gacie used between UFC 1 thru 4. He has the arn strength to put a guy like Big Show or Mark Henry in a choke hold if he can keep his grip regardless of how much they sway him. His only realistic offense would be either that or the movies taught to police to subdue people quickly.
In a collegiate bought he would be destroyed if he stayed in the heavyweight division..
JGlass said:
Have you ever tried lifting a 200+ pound man over your shoulders after spending the past 15 minutes fighting him and hoist him up with the greatest of ease? No, you haven't, because that is a ridiculous notion. So is expecting a guy to lie flat on the mat for 10 seconds while CM Punk ascends to the top turn buckle, poses for the crowd, and then drops an elbow. So is the idea that either Punk or his opponent can withstand a series of unprotected strikes and still be standing on their feet, only slightly worse for wear.
I've not seen any 15 minute matches, and rarely do.. Its not a rediculous notion, you can either lift it or you can't. If someone can bench 200 ten or fifteen times then they can lift a 200 pound man once even after going with him. If you've done your job in any fight the other guy is going to be sluggish and atleast dazed, in real fighting some arm drop in Macho Man fashion would be showboating but still doable if you harmed them enough.
You don't think a man can take those strikes and still be up you need to watch some footage of Jack Johnson in his prime.
Realism in wrestling is just something the IWC made up so they have something to complain about. Fact of the matter is that the best entertainers make us forget all about realism. Look at Hogan: he made a simple leg drop look like the deadliest move in the world. All the best wrestler manage to captivate us and forget all about the rules of the real world. Stone Cold did it. The Rock did it. John Cena does it. CM Punk does it.
His leg drop wasn't the kill shot it was the coup de grâce for an already weakened opponent. Nothing the Rock or Stone Cold did was unrealistic in any degree. They mostly punched then either slammed in the case of the Rock bottom or kicked in the gut in the case of the Stunner. You could do all of their moves in an actual fight and not lose ground over it.
Your point about the pile driver is even more weak. Any body who can't complete a powerbomb can turn that failure into a piledriver. Even when your opponent is 40 pounds heavier you just have to lean back and use his own weight against him with the help of gravity..
If you have this many doubts about the plausibility of moves why the hell don't you just have a shoot match with your friends and see if there is any impact when you give a legit leg drop or do a torture rack..
We can suspend disbelief when its reasonable OR AT LEAST plausible.. Even you would raise hell over Rey Mysterio giving Sheamus a jack knife power bomb..