JJYanks121
The Mouth of the South Shore
This is exactly what I was thinking. They put too much effort in to the BGF series to not have the first winner of it go on to be successful at Bound For Glory. I also believe that Hogan is exactly right here. I don't think Roode would have been half as interesting as champion as face as he would be as a heel. Not only did not putting the title on him at BFG work, but it made him into a legit superstar. Just at the sake of an awesome concept in the Bound For Glory series.
Here's the thing though, at what point do we start acknowledging the vicious cycle/pattern TNA has created. Whenever the company looks to have a champion for more than a month, they HAVE to be heel. Every since Hogoff came in, that's been the case. The only exception is RVD and I'd argue that RVD as champion wasn't the best idea. Great wrestler but never meant to be a top guy which is ok.
It seems like the company fears creating a major babyface wrestler. They have "flavors of the month" but anytime the fans want to get behind someone, they either lose and go to the back of the line or they become heel. Some examples of each:
Back of the line
-Mr. Anderson in 2010 (though he deserved it)
-Matt Morgan in late 2010. He got crazy over due to standing up for concussions but since the "story" was there for Anderson (a bad one at that as RVD should have been the BIG feud with Hardy and it never happened), Morgan lost two title matches and hasn't been seen near the title since. He could have been a GREAT face champion too.
-Velvet Sky. Gets a chance after two long years and despite lousy booking still gets a pop for winning the Knockouts title. Naturally she gets a 1 month reign and gets pushed aside despite being the most over knockout on the roster.
Had to turn heel
-AJ Styles-guy is having a solid reign and has become the face of the company which was well deserved so naturally he had to turn heel and become Flair Jr. This has been talked about ad-nauseum but the signs were there already of what was to come in this company.
-Jeff Hardy-I know, I know it was for the swerve. Still didn't make it a good idea, especially when either other guy turning (whether because they are evil or because the story is more complicated) would have been better.
-Mr. Anderson-Jeff fucked up so Immortal needed a champion, so naturally the guy who was most anti-Immortal joins because it wasn't ok to have a champion unassociated for over a month.
-Kurt Angle-this one made the least sense. For almost two years, this was a guy working with dignity. He had taken himself out of the top 10 and vowed to beat everyone or retire. He beat everyone and had his shot but Jeff screwed him. Forgetting the fact that he came back when he was supposed to retire, fans felt bad for him because he deserved that win. If anyone was TNA's top face, it was Angle, way moreso than Jeff or Mr. Anderson due to that story. So he feuds with Jarrett forever and he is the ultimate good guy as Jeff is the jerk. It finally ends and Angle gets in the title picture so a year's worth of struggle pays off so Angle can get on top as the company's top face right? WRONG. Angle turns heel and gives a shitty explanation on the next Impact. It was out of nowhere and it makes no sense.
-Bobby Roode-This is what the thread is about and we're finally here. Guy goes through everyone in 3 months kinda like Angle through his top 10 so he's built up to take the title. He's built up as a family man and a blue collar guy. I was actually impressed with this as I thought TNA was FINALLY building a major babyface to have as a company centerpiece. Then BFG happened and the finish was as anti-climactic as can be. A lot of people felt like the BFG series was wasted at that point. Now, I know the argument is "well Roode has been a good heel champion". That may be true, but you wasted a solid tournament to get to that. That tournament could have been a yearly thing but having the first guy lose doesn't do it wonders. I feel like this was just the latest though in this incessant fear that TNA has of building a major face. It's like someone told them "hey, having heel champions sells" so they only allow themselves that. The only face champions they have are there for short term to get to the next heel champ. Sounds a lot like an Atlanta based organization actually........hi Lex Luger's 6 day reign, how ya doing!
Plus, on top of everything else, this is Hogan giving an interview. Is anyone still taking him seriously?
Bottom line, based on the build, Roode should have won. If ANYONE felt he shouldn't, he never should have won the BFG series. It's really that simple.