I don't see him as either a hero or a traitor. If this is all completely legit, which I think is what most of us believe, then Punk feels he's doing what's best for him. It's his life and his career, so he doesn't owe the fans anything or anyone else for that matter. If Punk's just flat out burned out physically and mentally, then walking away might be what's best for him. If all the various reports are right, Punk hasn't squandered his money and has a net worth of $7.5 million, so it's not like he has anything to worry about financially.
As far as my own opinion, based simply on the same information that everyone else has read & heard about, I can see both sides of this thing. I can understand Punk being displeased about part timers like The Rock coming back, being given so much time, being made such a huge focal point while other guys bust their humps year round. I can understand his frustration at Batista being booked in the title match at WrestleMania XXX despite being gone for nearly 4 years. It becomes all the easier to understand his alleged frustrations towards the Batista situation when you consider that Batista isn't even remotely a star on the same level as The Rock. Even if you don't necessarily agree with The Rock or Batista getting such royal treatment, it's much easier to understand in The Rock's case but not for Batista.
At the same time, however, I do get that WWE management sees Batista as a huge star. While I personally think they've hugely overestimated just how big of a star he is, it's just my opinion. I also understand that WWE pushing Batista because they feel he's such a star is a business decision and isn't being done to screw over the other members of the roster, nor is it being done to gain some sort of perverse pleasure at holding other wrestlers back. I know it's a fairly common fantasy that a lot of internet fans have, but it's time to wake the fuck up and face reality. I don't believe that WWE management is made up of demonic sadists who get their jollies out of screwing over the wrestlers of their company.
As for Punk simply walking out and the reported reasons for his gripes and frustrations, again, I see both sides of it and both have merit. Punk does bust his ass on the road year round like every other member of the roster, so it's perfectly natural to feel a bit raw when someone who hasn't been around waltzes in and gets the top spot. Simply walking out the way he did without warning, in my opinion, was immature and unprofessional. There were a lot of fans in attendance that Monday night and Punk is one of the primary reasons they attended. Now while he may not owe fans by simply staying in WWE if he's unhappy, it's a different story when he just walks out of a show half an hour before it starts packed with people who paid to see him.
Again, I've no idea how much of the info that we've gotten over the past 1.5+ weeks is accurate, but I find myself growing less sympathetic for Punk as it goes by. Based on all this info, in a nutshell, Punk's primary reason for walking out seems to be that he simply isn't getting his way. He knows that he doesn't have to worry about money, so he's decided that he's going to quit since he's not being given exactly what he wants. Again, from the standpoint of a human being, I can understand that. I also understand that not getting your way sometimes is a fact of life, especially when that comes to your job. When you look back over the course of Punk's time in WWE, according to all the various reports that've been put out over the years, it
ALWAYS seems that Punk is disgruntled, frustrated or unhappy about something that's going on. It seems like he's always had something to piss & moan about.
Again, I understand being frustrated and I can't say that Punk is right or wrong for feeling that way. I'm not in his shoes, so I'm certain that I don't know the
ENTIRE story. However, at the same time, I've read that he makes roughly $1.25 million a year. I don't know if that's his downside guarantee or not. At any rate, based that, I can't be too sorry for a guy making about 28 times more than me.