Who can defeat Andre the Giant? | Page 3 | WrestleZone Forums

Who can defeat Andre the Giant?

Except a prime Ryback didn't even go over Punk, who we both agree is bad.

Yeah, Ryback was probably a poor choice of words, but still, Andre would be used to build monster babyfaces. That's exactly what you do with the big guy. He's no different than the Giant/Big Show. I mean, remember when he was billed as Andre's kid?
 
Legit question - are we booking Andre with the kayfabe still on or not? Because that is a game changer. Andre in the current WWE would probably be a Great Khali of some sorts (Khali is however a lot popular in India). Andre in his 70's/80's run would crush a guy like Ryback every Wednesday. Sometimes two like him in handicap matches. He only lost clean to big big stars such as Canek in Mexico or Inoki in Japan. We also need to see if he's a babyface or a heel, because heels lose, big babyfaces rarely do. If Hogan was #1, Andre was #1,5 by WWF's scale in 1980's.
 
How far did you have to dig up your ass to pull that out?
Point three was at least wrist deep.

CM Punk beat him last year or the year before in a ladder match. He will be eliminated in the gimmick match rounds like he always is.
Punk's ladder and TLC match record makes me comfortable with my choice. Especially when you consider how well men of Andre's size fare in those bouts

Chris Jericho would beat Andre and it would be a squash match.
You'd think so. But you can generally bank on Jericho making it much farther in the tournament than he ought to.
 
Just for the record, Andre's legacy as a draw has been grossly inflated by contemporary historians.

He was still big (in a metaphorical sense - just not that big). Oh, and he lost to Don Leo Jonathon.
 
Hackenschmit, Gotch, Lewis, George(not really, but whatever), Thesz, Rikidozan, Rogers, Rocca, Sammartino, Inoki, Flair, Hogan, Santo, Austin, Rock, Taker.

You're welcome.

Hackenschmit (I didn't look up the spelling first time, not going to now) and George should probably be replaced by Cena and Sheik (the good one) but whatever.
 
I could see Taker beating Andre, its certainly plausible he could. Every wrestler ever talks about how awesome Taker is, he's often considered the greatest gimmick of all time, his character alone makes it a possibility so its possible.

Andre was the bigger draw no question and he definitely the advantage but I could see Taker winning if they face off.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
174,846
Messages
3,300,837
Members
21,727
Latest member
alvarosamaniego
Back
Top