Hmm do ya really want me to spoil the surprise for you? You should have more faith in the writers. Nothing that's happened is unexplainable and I'm fairly confident you don't want me to explain because it'd ruin it for you.
Your confidence is sorely misplaced. I could care less about surprises, so if you think you know the answer to the Libby scenario, let's see it.
And don't talk to people you've never met as if you know them.
I can give you two possible explanations behind the kidnapping.
I don't want possible explanations, i want THE explanation.
Jacob wanted them separated from the candidates for their own safety or as a test.
A test of what? To see if they'd get them back? Because if that's it then they failed miserably. The only person out of about 20 they got back was Claire because Alex freed her. You could say Walt as well, but Michael got him back, and he's not a candidate.
Or maybe it was to see if they'd go all gun crazy when one of them disappeared. Failed that as well then didn't they?
MIB conned the Others into taking them in order to piss off the candidates.
How? Ben is the only person who receives orders from Jacob, and that was from the hut which has now been burned down. And if that's the case, why are Cindy and the kids STILL there 3 years later. If he just wants to fuck with the minds of the candidates, why would he encourage them to incorporate those people into the Others society permenantly? He's apparently going to kill everyone anyway, so why would he want them to add to their numbers?
And as far as Jacob wanting conmen etcetera, he was the reason they went in that direction in the first place. Candidates have to be able to learn from their mistakes and redeem themselves.
So why is Hurley a candidate? The guy won the lottery, suffered a buckewtload of trauma, stress and tragedy, went nuts twice and then had to run for his life because Sayid killed a bunch of assassins. So at what point did Hurley ever do anything, which would result in him having to redeem himself?
You know that film the butterfly effect? Well assume it's bullshit. Changing things in the past doesn't majorly change the future.
No, it's all bullshit because time travel is bullshit.
In the case of John, Alpert never tells him or his mum that he's special,
Foster-mother actually. Plus if i recall, Richard left saying that they'd made a mistake and that John was not special.
John never feels that injustice
What injustice? Obviously this isn't something that weighed heavily on his mind his whole life, otherwise he'd have recognised Richard the first time he saw him on the island.
and things turn out differently with his dad. That doesn't mean John can't end up in a wheelchair via some other way.
Yeah, my point is, I want to know
how it did happen in the altered timeline. Was it really that unclear?
I really don't understand your mentality. You want all the secrets to come out in the first episodes? The clues are already there
No, however it'd be nice to be given answers to questions that were raised 5 seasons ago before the show ends. At this point i'm expecting a segment on the Season 6 bonus features where the writers read every letter asking them 'WTF happened with....' where they just turn around and say 'Oh shit, we forgot about that!' over and over again.
Because Sawyer was looking in that direction? If someone appeared in front of you, wouldn't you assume it's normal instead of thinking "Hey there's a kid I don't know, how come I can see him" Come on now, think things through
I asked why he can see him when Richard can't, not why can he see him in general. Come on now, read the post properly before you respond to it. Anyway, it's probably related to the fact that Sawyer's a candidate.
Maybe he didn't want to appear as Smokey infront of Sawyer?
What's the point in that? Sawyer knows he isn't Locke so why bother hiding it anymore? Plus he ran off quite deep into the jungle while Sawyer was talking to Richard, so he wasn't even watching what MIB was doing.
Being too occupied with the image of the kid to think straight, would have been a better answer.
That was explained in the cave
Remind me then, because all i remember was some talk about candidates being chose to defend the island against something. There was no talk of rules or anything else, which again, is what i was questioning.
That's one of the few things I've not got any idea about. What I have been considering is that those born on the island seem to be special. That or it's possible that Jacob simply gave them.
So much for 'nothing is unexplanable' eh?