I've always thought Johansson was beautiful. I guess I just never payed too much attention to Hathaway. To me, she was always just that woman who starred in The Princess Diaries films.
For her hotness, watch Havoc. Horrible film, but she was unbelievably sexy in it.
For her talent, watch Rachel Getting Married. Superb performance from her in that.
And for a little bit of both, watch Love and Other Drugs.