The Undertaker is my favorite wrestler of all time. Shawn Michaels is a great wrestler, and I have always enjoyed his ring work as well as his mic work. So I am not here to complain about their match or give reasons why I think they should or should not have this rematch. I just want to come up with a way(s) to have this rematch without hurting either of their legacy's.
So let's look at the facts...
If The Undertaker wins, his streak continues, and Shawn Michaels must retire.
If Shawn Michaels wins, the Undertaker's streak is broken, and essentially, his most notable accomplishment is completely wiped away.
Note: In my opinion, if the Undertaker loses, it is almost the equivalent of retiring because that magical presence surrounding him will be gone. He will be like all the others...a man who HAS lost at Wrestlemania.
So how can we have an outcome that won't dramatically affect either superstar's career and keep the majority of fans happy? In my opinion, there are 2 possible ways to do so...depending on who wins, of course. We must also keep in mind that Shawn Michaels plans to take time off until Summerslam, and The Undertaker also plans to take a considerable break.
Scenario 1: The Undertaker wins.
Since the Undertaker wins, Shawn Michaels MUST retire. Both men are taking time off anyway, though. This means that starting the very, next night on Raw, all of our attention will focus on grudge matches for Backlash, new rivalries, and the draft. And since Summerslam won't be for another 4 and a half months, most fans will easily be able to forget The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels. This brings me to my idea. I believe The Undertaker should return around July and compete in that month's PPV (whatever that'll be called now). He should compete in a high profile match against a high profile superstar, but it should have NOTHING to do with the championship. He should win a hard fought match and seemingly end the rivalry, but at the Smackdown following the PPV, his opponent and a credible, new ally will team up and brutally attack The Undertaker. After several beatings, we think The Undertaker has nothing left, but he cuts a promo and decides he needs a partner...a partner who he respects and who fears nobody...a partner like...HBK! Fast forward, fast forward...we don't see or hear from HBK. All we know is that he has accepted The Undertaker's offer to come out of retirement and team up with him at Summerslam. Now, all of a sudden, you have a legitimate reason for Shawn to return, and quite frankly, a cool, new storyline with The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels actually teaming up together instead of feuding with each other.
Scenario 2: Shawn Michaels wins.
Since Shawn Michaels wins, obviously, The Undertaker's streak will be over. That's a tough pill to swallow, and while it may not hurt the overall legacy of The Undertaker, I think that magical presence surrounding him would be gone. We would not be able to see him anymore as "The Phenom" but rather as a first ballot Hall of Famer who should probably hang up the boots. And really, what more would there be for him to accomplish? To me, 18-1, 20-1, or 50-1, it's all the same...it's close but no cigar. It's not undefeated. It's not unbeatable. It's not perfect. So how can we cushion the blow? We do this. Both men take their time off and come back whenever. Summerslam is fine. Months will have gone by, and we'll be talking about John Cena, HHH, and the usual suspects again. Hell, maybe we'll even have some new, main event pushes. Eitherway, The Undertaker/Shawn Michaels storyline will have subsided. So they come back on SEPARATE shows and stay apart from one another. Then, around the time of The Slammy's (like last year), maybe their match wins "Match of the Year" again. Only this time, The Undertaker asks for a rematch with Shawn Michaels. And from there, we get the opposite. Shawn Michaels declines The Undertaker's challenges and says he has already taken his streak. He has nothing more to prove. And from there we go through a similar routine with The Undertaker pushing for a rubber match. Finally, they agree to have one, final match to settle everything, and this time, it is officially a "Career vs. Career" match. The Undertaker wins the rubber match, Shawn Michaels retires, and essentially, The Undertaker avenges his lone Wrestlemania loss. And 20 years from now, when we look back at his final Wrestlemania record and see that 1 blemish, we can always remember that, "yes, he may have lost to Shawn Michaels, BUT he did avenge that loss, and took the overall series of Wrestlemania matches."
So let's look at the facts...
If The Undertaker wins, his streak continues, and Shawn Michaels must retire.
If Shawn Michaels wins, the Undertaker's streak is broken, and essentially, his most notable accomplishment is completely wiped away.
Note: In my opinion, if the Undertaker loses, it is almost the equivalent of retiring because that magical presence surrounding him will be gone. He will be like all the others...a man who HAS lost at Wrestlemania.
So how can we have an outcome that won't dramatically affect either superstar's career and keep the majority of fans happy? In my opinion, there are 2 possible ways to do so...depending on who wins, of course. We must also keep in mind that Shawn Michaels plans to take time off until Summerslam, and The Undertaker also plans to take a considerable break.
Scenario 1: The Undertaker wins.
Since the Undertaker wins, Shawn Michaels MUST retire. Both men are taking time off anyway, though. This means that starting the very, next night on Raw, all of our attention will focus on grudge matches for Backlash, new rivalries, and the draft. And since Summerslam won't be for another 4 and a half months, most fans will easily be able to forget The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels. This brings me to my idea. I believe The Undertaker should return around July and compete in that month's PPV (whatever that'll be called now). He should compete in a high profile match against a high profile superstar, but it should have NOTHING to do with the championship. He should win a hard fought match and seemingly end the rivalry, but at the Smackdown following the PPV, his opponent and a credible, new ally will team up and brutally attack The Undertaker. After several beatings, we think The Undertaker has nothing left, but he cuts a promo and decides he needs a partner...a partner who he respects and who fears nobody...a partner like...HBK! Fast forward, fast forward...we don't see or hear from HBK. All we know is that he has accepted The Undertaker's offer to come out of retirement and team up with him at Summerslam. Now, all of a sudden, you have a legitimate reason for Shawn to return, and quite frankly, a cool, new storyline with The Undertaker and Shawn Michaels actually teaming up together instead of feuding with each other.
Scenario 2: Shawn Michaels wins.
Since Shawn Michaels wins, obviously, The Undertaker's streak will be over. That's a tough pill to swallow, and while it may not hurt the overall legacy of The Undertaker, I think that magical presence surrounding him would be gone. We would not be able to see him anymore as "The Phenom" but rather as a first ballot Hall of Famer who should probably hang up the boots. And really, what more would there be for him to accomplish? To me, 18-1, 20-1, or 50-1, it's all the same...it's close but no cigar. It's not undefeated. It's not unbeatable. It's not perfect. So how can we cushion the blow? We do this. Both men take their time off and come back whenever. Summerslam is fine. Months will have gone by, and we'll be talking about John Cena, HHH, and the usual suspects again. Hell, maybe we'll even have some new, main event pushes. Eitherway, The Undertaker/Shawn Michaels storyline will have subsided. So they come back on SEPARATE shows and stay apart from one another. Then, around the time of The Slammy's (like last year), maybe their match wins "Match of the Year" again. Only this time, The Undertaker asks for a rematch with Shawn Michaels. And from there, we get the opposite. Shawn Michaels declines The Undertaker's challenges and says he has already taken his streak. He has nothing more to prove. And from there we go through a similar routine with The Undertaker pushing for a rubber match. Finally, they agree to have one, final match to settle everything, and this time, it is officially a "Career vs. Career" match. The Undertaker wins the rubber match, Shawn Michaels retires, and essentially, The Undertaker avenges his lone Wrestlemania loss. And 20 years from now, when we look back at his final Wrestlemania record and see that 1 blemish, we can always remember that, "yes, he may have lost to Shawn Michaels, BUT he did avenge that loss, and took the overall series of Wrestlemania matches."