They both suck, neither should go through simple as. Both are overated to fook, Rey was a decent crusierweight about 5 years ago, but he has been over pushed and really isnt anything remotely special. However sid was even more over pushed, he was never anything other than a average mid/lower card wrestler. He was made to look good because of his size, and his push. However I am voting for Sid because I hate Rey sooo much, because he is crap, whereas i am pretty neutral towards sid, and even enjoyed a couple of his matches. The only Rey match I have ever liked was his ladder match with eddie.