1. Eddie Guerrero - It's pretty obvious. He was a tremendous entertainer and one of the best wrestlers to ever step foot in the WWE ring. He had great technical skills, aerial skills and just all-around everything. I was glad that he won the WWE Championship at least once in his career. He was hilarious too.
2. Tazz - He's my favourite wrestler of all-time. That's not the only reason why I'd love to see him return to the ring. He was always the little guy in ECW that overcame the big guys and posed as a major threat to anyone. He revolutionized the 'attitude' of ECW as much as Sabu and RVD revolutionized high risk maneuvers. It was a shame that the WWE misused him just because of his size. He had the mic skills, the intensity, the technical skills and an amazing set of suplexes. He was the only WWE wrestler under WWE contract to win the ECW World Heavyweight Championship and fight then-WWE Champion Triple H on Smackdown in an interpromotional match. I just wish he didn't have any injuries or else he'd still probably be able to compete from time to time like Lawler.
3. Brock Lesnar - He had everything. He had the intensity, the endurance and the strength to tangle with anyone in the WWE. He was a freakin' monster and man-handled people, which was something that the WWE was simply missing. The thing is, Lesnar had actual in-ring skills, because he was also a former NCAA Champion and his Manster image went over with the fans. In a short time, he held the WWE Championship three times already and if that's not impressive, look at all the matches that he had. He took out The Rock cleanly and he took out the Undertaker cleanly.
4. Bret "The Hitman" Hart - He was my favourite WWF wrestler of all-time. He had the influence and the technical skills that made him display so much passion for wrestling. Very few were able to defeat Bret Hart and because of his endurance, he was able to win the WWF Championship five times. He did it all in the ring and he was one of the only wrestlers that could go toe-to-toe with Stone Cold Steve Austin and not be intimidated. Bret Hart had a lot of classic matches and made wrestling look like hard work (which it really is) instead of some regular show for entertainment. He made the WWF title pretty prestigious while he had it too.
5. Stone Cold Steve Austin - Stone Cold brought the attitude to the WWF and pretty much made everyone mark out with his signature -- The Stone Cold Stunner. He's a multi-time Royal Rumble winner and multi-time WWF Champion. He was at Wrestlemanias when he won his WWF titles a couple of times too. Not a lot of superstars have that. He also had the influence much like Bret Hart and really elevated the WWF to look much more 'hardcore.' He brought a whole new meaning to WWF wrestling and beat the best and most popular superstars during his time. He was just exciting to watch and has that instant recognition as an icon.