Indeed, I would be doing him (and my 2 other roomies) a favor by throwing it away lol but still.... I'm thinking of pulling a small prank similar to what I once did to my roomie from freshman year.
He kept wanting to play one of my Gamecube games, I can't remember which.... I think it was Ocarina of Time's Master Quest version.... I started by putting Smash Bros Melee in the Gamecube. Then put Sonic Mega Collection in Smash Bros Melee's box, True Crimes was put in Sonic Mega Collection's box, another game was then put in True Crimes' box, and so on the cycle repeats until all of my games were in the wrong box. He ended up falling for it and had to go through every single one of my gamecube boxes (a dozen or so?) to find the game he wanted to play.... it was hilarious, he even took the time to put them all back in their right boxes, which made it even funnier.
There are like 8 DVD's out there and I could easily pull this same prank off again, but I should add a note or something in the box that Zohan ends up being in that says "Wow, I can't believe you fell for that" or something.
I think it'd be a funny and harmless thing to do to get back at him for leaving that DVD on all night for nearly a whole week.