My problem with the OP is that he makes a lot of unsubtantiated claims about younger wrestlers who "havnt stepped up" or who are flatout "terrible", without actually backing it up. In fact not only are the claims unsubtantiated; they often fly in the face of the reality of what is actually happening.
Orton: Was great as a bad guy but he needs to have a evolution as a character. If not he won't stay on top.
He's not one of my favs, but Orton has done an exceptional job repacking himself throughout his career, from cocky, cowardly heel in the beginning, to cocky, tough heel in Evolution, to his legend killer gimmick, to his sadistic "psycho" persona while feuding with Triple H, to his current gimmick, which is sort of that of a loner with psychotic tendancies but with a sort of personal moral code. His character is CONSTANTLY evolving.
CM Punk: Is great but for whatever reason he hasn't found the single story to propel him as being seen as the man in the WWE.
Is insanely over and is becomming moreso every week. As JR said in his twitter, he really "looked like a star" at the Elimination Chamber PPV, moreso than ever. He is getting monster heat as the demented head of Nexus, which is the most engaging storyline in wrestling right now. If he's doing this well right now, and if the momentum continues, then just imagine how over he'll be in a couple of years (when the current "big names" are all gone). We'll be calling Punk a "legend" in five years time.
John Cena: ... I won't say that Cena was forced on us when he was the rapping Cena and was one of the hottest wrestlers in the WWE when he was on Smackdown... once he moved to RAW and was turned into Hogan Jr. it has been puke worthy.
See, this just flies in the face of reality. Under his cuddly, family-friendly babyface persona, Cena has been selling a fucktonne of merchandise. The kids LOVE him. It's not that he's being forced down our throats, it's that people WANT to see him, are prepared to pay money to see him, and so WWE are responding accordingly and giving the people what they want. YOU may find him puke-worthy in his current persona, but this has no relevence in the context of whether or not WWE will be in trouble when the "big names" retire. It has no relevence because your opinion of Cena does not change the fact that he's a draw and a cash-cow.
You also went on to say that
- Del Rio and Sheamus are "terrible": The fact is that both of these guys are getting over, especially Del Rio who is drawing major heat for someone who has just stepped into the picture. You're in a minority with your view on Del Rio, whether in the company of IWC members like ourselves, or the marks comprising the so-called "WWE universe". The guy is over as hell, is a born main-eventer, and (barring something unforseen) will be a great draw for the WWE for years to come.
Sheamus' rise has been more gradual, but he is now an established upper-card heel; I think most people would say that he has been gradually improving every week since he started, and is now a very solid worker. He will only get better.
- Morrison has not stepped up: "Stepping up" is such a vague term that it is hard to either prove or disprove what you've said, but the fact is that -slowly but surely- he has IMMENSELY improved over the last two years. As I see it, he has been in a transitional stage for the last few months, adding new "tweeks" to his character and his look, and trying to incorporate a little bit of ring psychology into his matches instead of being a pure "spot monkey"; high spots will always be his game, but it is evident that he's trying to become a more complete wrestler. It is too glib and simplistic to say "he hasnt stepped up"; he is very much in the process of stepping up, but it takes time and we'll see if he's up to it over the course of the next year or two.
- Daniel Brian is not over because he is not being used correctly: I totally agree that WWE does not have a good track record when it comes to booking wrestlers of Brians ilk. The "ladies man" gimmick doesnt suit him. But he's managed to make it work to the greatest extent possible, and he IS over. The plus-side is that this ladies-man/affable nerd crap has not hurt his character; he is still taken seriously by the fans. Eventually, they'll give him something else to work with, hopefully something that suits him better; a no-nonsense ring technician who will break your neck as soon as look at you would seem the obvious choice. I'm hopeful that in a couple of years, he'll be a Benoit-style fringe main-eventer.
Honestly, the WWE has been doing a good job with its youth policy in the last 12 months; if I have one criticims it is that they should have started a year or two earlier. If the veterans retired
right now, then the WWE would be in a lot of trouble. But all of the young guys you've mentioned (not to mention Barrett, Kofi Kingston, etc) will only become bigger stars in the next year or two, especially as the big name veterans you speak of start to put them over on their way out, just like Snuka put 'Taker over and the Warrior put Trip... well, you know what I mean.