First off, thank you everybody for voicing your opinions. I had no idea this thread would take off like it did, and a lot of people brought up a lot of good reasons for and against TNA being in trouble. I'll try to give even more reasoning behind my first post, but first...
"Hulk Hogan, Ric Flair, Kurt Angle, AJ Styles, Sting, Team 3D, Jeff Hardy...these guys sell out buildings."
Those guys don't ALWAYS sell out buildings. Hogan could sell out WM 7 so they changed the venue. Hogan and Flair couldn't sell out WCW in 94-96 in various arena's. Aj Styles, Sting, 3D couldn't sell out a 2,500 person arena. And Hardy, I want to see what he can draw without WWE's kids viewership
I want to add to my first post but I want to address a few things.
First off, I am in no way a TNA hater, and that's really an immature and stupid term to use. I liked the X Division, I liked Joe, I really like Styles, and Pope, and Beer Money and the womens division and Wolfe, Angle, Hernadez (actually knew him quite well, wrestled in the Humble Bingo Hall 30 minutes from Houston). My problem with TNA is over the years they have taken away what made them different. What originally made me go "Ok, this is different then WWE, I like this". Those things are long gone now.
And WCW was the same way. Cruiserweights became an afterthought when nWo just started to eat Nitro.
I think it's well known I think Hogan is a piece of shit. Because he is. It's also well known I don't watch the WWE very much. I haven't watched a whole WWE PPV since WM, since I was there.
The point of this thread, and I think I missed it, and need explain it further.
Hogan was hailed as the savior. The final piece to compete with WWE. Only problem is, Hogan doesn't seem to have a clue what he is doing. His supposed faces are heels, and his heels are faces, he is getting boo'd, matches for free on 1/4 were main events at Genesis. Changing the ring without letting the talent know.
TNA is a family. I know they say it like a gimmick but it really is. ECW was a family. I enjoyed both of them up to a point. But, and this is what Hogan fails to see. If you take what makes TNA unique away, then they have NO chance to survive. I understand WHY the ring was changed. But then again I understand it made TNA unique. And if you take away the X Division, take away a mid carders title, take away the 6 sides, take away the Ultimate X match, you start taking away what attracted most people away from WWE in the first place WITHOUT first adding some new viewers then you have a problem.
TNA can't beat WWE at their own game. WWE has perfected it. They shut down WCW with it. So you need to take your own flavor, your own vibe and just add pieces around it
And one poster, and I can't remember his name, made a brilliant observation. TNA are fighting, clawing, bringing in every name they can think of, and frankly besides the Rock and Austin they have nobody left to call. Maybe RVD but that's about it. Point is, TNA IS fighting right now, they are bringing their big guns early and all they had to show for was a .2 better than their all time high.
WWE isn't doing jack. Bret Hart STILL won't be appearing on Raw tonight. What happens if Vince says fuck it, lets kill it before it gets big and starts to switch to better programs? Longer feuds, more violence. They take a gamble and turn Cena heel, remove Hornswallows, break DX up, yadda yadda. What if Vince wakes up and starts to produce a quality wrestling product again. Then TNA is dead to rights.
Reminds me of paintball, if you ever played it. You got guys up front, couple in middle, 1 or two in the back. You attack, but if you fail with your attack you still have the back and middle to potentially hold it down and defend your flag. TNA seems to have everybody in the front line with nobody defending the flag, and WWE seems to be defending the flag with everyone they have and nobody is attacking. So which one will lose? The guys attacking leaving their base unguarded.
TNAs problem is what WCWs was towards the end. They think wrestling fans have short memories and in some cases it's true. But in alot of ways they don't. Fans don't understand how Abyss is the supposed hardcore icon yet brass knuckles puts him down. They can't take Daniels seriously when last month he was good enough to challenge AJ for the title, but this month he couldn't beat Morey who was a WWE jobber last year. They can't take X division seriously when their champion hardly ever gets air time, and their big match ends in a huge clusterfuck on Jan 4th. You just can't erase the past and start a clean slate. Doesn't work like that.