1. HHH would have been like Booker T??? u mean like in a tag team with goldust? Come on dude stop the blind hatred. HHH has how many classics compared to Booker T? That comparison shows that you are certainly biased because it is completely ridiculous. HHH did more before he even married Steph than Booker did in his entire career. HHH being like Y2J is a fair argument, I just dont agree with it. HHH's physique and charisma would have easily put him above Y2J's level. Nobody was built like HHH and you know Vince loves big guys.
When I say HHH would have been like Booker T, I mean in terms of NOW, so I am not saying he would have been in a comedy tag team. I am saying that without Steph, he would have been (as of today) in a Jericho type position where he comes back and can main event or be upper midcard enhancement when necessary or in a Booker type position where he is a backstage presence, wrestles occasionally, gets an onscreen role/HOF induction and probably runs his own small time promotion.
As for your other point, HHH before Steph had 1 world title. At that point, unless I'm mistaken, Booker had a world title too. I'd call that pretty equal footing. And did you really just say Booker has no classics compared to HHH? Booker had 2 boss ass Best of 7's with Benoit; pick a match. I can't name even 3 HHH classics, much less 14 (I'll get to that later).
2. HHH has NOT main evented 5 Mania's where he came out on top. Did you just make that up? He's actually closed 6 WM's not 5. HHH is 3-3 at Mania closing matches if my memory is correct. He lost to Benoit, Batista, and Cena; he defeated Y2J, Rock, and Orton.
And my point was that every time he came out on top, it sucked donkey nuts. Whether it was 6 or 5 he closed (it was 6, but I was only talking about the ones he won) is an irrelevant case to argue. He WON 4 Main Event WM matches (by main event I mean a world title match or a closer), and each one of those wins, as I've already stated, are infamous for some reason or another:
-He should not have gone over Rock at 16 even though that match was overbooked anyway;
-His chance at being the knight in shining armor by beating Jericho was squashed because it was not fit to close (he was in the right to have won, but it should not have closed the show. That, or it should have been good enough not to bore the crowd to death)
-He damn sure did not need to beat Booker at 19. It ruined Booker's first face main event run in WWE when he was probably the most over face on RAW, it was quite offensive considering the racial tone that the buildup had, it lead to a shitty feud with Kevin Nash and the way he ended the match was just disgusting.
-I personally didn't care whether he won or lost 25 as either would have been an OK decision, but once again, his closer sucked and got outshined by a greater preceding match contested by greater superstars.
3. The shovel argument is biased in its own right. Nobody rates Austin, Rock, or Hogan any lower even though they NEVER really put anyone over. Hogan did once he was older and in WCW but HHH has lost to more youngsters than any of these three. I cant remember Austin putting anyone over EVER!!
Hogan, as you already said, was an ass and didn't put over a lot of folks, but he did so later in his career to Brock, Rock and in WCW.
Rock put over Angle, Jericho, Benoit, Booker T (ironically so he could face and be buried by HHH), Brock Lesnar, HHH, and hell, even the freakin' Hurricane. Don't tell me Rock never put anyone over.
Austin didn't put anyone effectively over, truth. However, this does not make it okay for HHH to follow suit. It just means they're both asses in that regard. Besides, not putting over doesn't equal bury. The only person I can say Austin buried was maybe Kane (maybe). HHH undeniably buried shitloads more.
4. Booker T is and has ALWAYS been a lower mid card talent. Booker T has NEVER done anything special. He wasnt good in the ring and he never cut good promos. He was a black Santino that wcw pushed while they were terrible and going out of business. HHH didnt bury Booker...Booker had no upside at all.
Bullshit. Booker was a main eventer in the 3 major promotions for a reason (WWE, WCW, TNA) and it's not because there was no one else to push. He was BETTER in the ring than Hunter for damn sure (HHH is a better ring psychologist, that's it), and on the mic he did more than hold his own, hence the reason he was put on commentary. Booker winning world titles in WCW while it was dying might have been a viable argument for him being overrated, but you forget he then won one in WWE that many fans agree was LONG overdure. HHH did bury Booker. Rock went ahead and put him over for a match with HHH that had literally only 4 or 5 weeks of buildup, and in that 4 or 5 weeks he became the most over face on RAW sans Austin. Sure, he was in a comedy tag team before, but that doesn't mean immediate irrelevance. Hell, Rock was in a comedy tag team while he was the face of the damn company. And plus, Booker and Goldie were tag champs. He was plucked from it because they were over as shit and he was good enough to do it. Then HHH puts race into his promos and pretty much does all but call Booker a minstrel show (which was a damn good idea), but then has the nerve to basically make racism look okay by beating Booker in the most embarrassingly slow pinfall attempt I have ever seen. That alone makes Booker a better professional than HHH ever was.
5. HHH beating Y2J made perfect sense. Why the hell would someone return from and injury that kept them out for almost a year to one of the biggest pops in history, win the royal rumble, than lose at WM? What kind of booking would that be? That makes no sense and I dont understand why people dont realize that.
I never said HHH should have lost to Jericho. I just said he shouldn't have sucked so hard in beating him. This might sound harsh, but I mean goddamn: you are following 2 legends in Rock/Hogan and you KNOW you need to tear the roof off the place, which is not hard considering Jericho's in the ring with you and Hogan can't wrestle for sh*t at this stage in his career. Is it so much to ask that you either not close the show or do better than the match before? What's even worse is that he let this happen AGAIN at WM25. Face it: HHH's is best served on his back if he's closing WM's. Give the shine to someone the fans care to see it on.