Good list, which actually helps me prove my point. I wasn't saying Morrison should never be champ, I was going for the possibility that even he did become champ, his lack of mic skills would prevent him from being a consistent headliner. He could conceivably become champ, but would soon be relegated to the midcard soon after his reign (for future reference, i mean midcard to upper mid card) Let's break down your list and see how the past supports my argument.
Bob Backlund - The guy had Above Average mic skills. Became champ, lost it within 3 days or so, back to mid carding
I think you're confused. You're refering to Backlund's second "run" with the company. At that time he was far older and past his prime. But in his first "run" with the company he held the championship for YEARS and was the face of the company during that time. And no, Backlund didn't have above average mic skills.
Andre The Giant - He had Bobby Heenan as his manager and talker,one of the greatest managers of all time. Besides, Andre was already a superstar and all time great even before he won the WWF title. Here's a fun fact for you, his WWF title reign lasted 15 seconds.
Yes he only had a very brief reign as champion, but you were referencing roles as main eventers and headliners. Andre the Giant was a headliner for YEARS, and didn't need the championship to be in the main event scene. You're right though, Andre was a superstar before he won the championship, which is the point. He was without any mic skills.
Ultimate Warrior - He has no mic skills obviously. His promos were rants basically. But they fit in with his character. And his in-ring skills weren't that great. Going back to the point, after he won the title, what happened to him? Back to mid carding, never the same success.
Not a valid point. Ultimate Warrior dropped out of the main event scene after his first run with the title solely because of back stage problems and coming and going from the company sporadically. That had nothing to do with him as a wrestler. The WWE would've had him as one of their top stars for years and years if he hadn't messed that up continually because of personal problems and business issues. Morrison isn't in that situation.
Yokozuna - He had Jim Cornette and Mr. Fuji as managers, they did the talking. After a one year dominant run as WWF champ, he lost to Bret Hart at WM X that started the Bret Hart Era. He went back to mid-carding.
Once again this isn't a valid comparison to Morrison. Yokozuna was a dominant champion for a year without any mic skills. The only reason he dropped from being a main eventer was ENTIRELY because of his weight issues, otherwise he'd have continued to be a consistent main eventer. Obviously Morrison doesn't have those problems.
Jeff Hardy - I'll be honest, I never followed Hardy's title reign. But from what I gather, he went back to mid carding and is now in TNA nowhere near WWF main event status
Incorrect again. Hardy was a top main eventer right up until he left the company, and now he's a top main eventer for TNA. TNA may not be on WWE's level, but Hardy is still one of their top stars and World champions. And he has no mic skills doing so.
Kane - Had Paul Bearer talking for him, that's true. And he held the WWF title for one day when that happened. When he lost Paul Bearer and developed his mic skills, he went his championship reign last year. But after how many years was that? And where is he now? Back to mid card.
Who cares whether he had a short championship reign once? He just had a long championship reign most recently, too. And Kane may have gone up and down from main event to mid card, but he's still consistently been put in the main event scene over the course of his entire career in the WWE. That's a fact.
Benoit - He had the WM 20 moment. Then what? Lost the title after 5 months, went back to mid card
Just because you lose the title doesn't mean you're not in the main event. If you're still competing for the championship regularly, and still in main event level feuds, then you're a main event level star. And before Benoit's death and the whole fiasco that revolved around it, Benoit was about to be the ECW champion and the top star on the ECW brand, which could've easily brought him right back into the main event going into the future.
Goldberg - He had below average mic skills. But at least he was on the mic, which I can't say the same for JoMo who is NEVER on the mic. We can never tell where he would have went as his contract was one year, which was basically a 8 month reign as main eventer plus WM match with Brock.
Goldberg was a main eventer in WCW for years. He was one of their top stars for years. He had no mic skills doing it. When he came to the WWE he was right in the main event, won the championship. Yes, his time in the WWE was short, but he was always a main eventer throughout his career and that would've continued. Despite him not having mic skills.
The point with Morrison is, history is not on his side. IF HE DOESN'T develop the mic skills, sure he can get a title run, but what happens after? If the JoMo fans out there just want to see him win the title, then don't worry, it's going to happen sooner or later. Just don't be surprised if he's back to the mid card after his reign.
But if the JoMo fans out there want him to succeed and become a consistent main eventer, then they at least have to acknowledge the need for a manager or drastic improvement on the mic.
No, there's no reason why John Morrison can't be a consistent main eventer for years to come. His mic skills aren't that bad, and certainly not as bad as some people seem to be making them out to be. Hell, he's in high profile feuds and competing for the World titles even now, and is always excelling when he does in those matches and feuds (which is why his popularity and star is on the rise).
And I feel your view is confusing, since many main eventers move up and down from the mid-card when they're not in the title picture. It's all about a cycle, a star will feud for the championship for a while and then eventually someone will take their place and the odd man out will feud with someone else in a more mid-card level until he's back up in a run for the championship. Chris Jericho has done it time and time again, but he's always a main event star. Kane is the same. CM Punk, too. Rey Mysterio. The list goes on and on. Look at Sheamus right now? He's been champion several times and in the main event, but over the past while he's been in mid-card feuds. He'll be back in the main event, and a champion again, though. He's a future star for the company, just like Morrison will be.