If we're looking at purely WWE guys, i'd say Taker.
-Yes HBK did a lot during the Monday Night War, but so did Taker, Austin, Bret first and foremost, but all the other guys in the Hart Foundation as well, and later on Foley, Rock and HHH all helped make WWE the no.1 brand. HBK was also injured during the crucial years of the War, which i believe is when the ratings started going back in their favour so what does that say?
- I never appreciated Hogan's ring work but then im a guy who got into wrestling in the attitude era, where spots, finishers, etc had evolved to a degree.
- Flair is another greatest of all time guy, but i never felt his NWA style really fit into 90's style wrestling. I adopted the ECW attitude of "Wrestling needs to get away from the NWA style," but you can't fault Flair for promos at any point in his career.
Fact is Taker has been involved in a number of innovating matches. First Casket match, first Buried Alive match, first HIAC, first Inferno match, first Boiler Room Brawl etc etc. HBK great entertainer yes, so was Taker throughout the 90's and anytime after where he was heel. HBK's moves list didn't update much in the 4 years he was gone, whereas Taker adds a new move to his arsenal every year! Takers' Mania matches won't b as good as HBK's now because we know that he'll win every year and i can't see Taker losing at Mania unless its his retirement match nor will it be any sooner than Wrestlemania 28 where he'll attempt to go 20-0, but Taker's health has to hold out for that to happen (plus he's gotta WANT to do it for that long)
My vote = Taker (by no means objective because Taker and Foley are the reasons igot into wrestling so...)