The last couple of years I have kinda noticed that the people who win the Royal Rumble are main eventers already, let's travel back in time...
Randy Orton,
John Cena,
Undertaker.
WWE has done 3 "established main event" winners in a row, however, they all were justified. Randy Orton's win was rather expected, because he was the hot feud going in, and everybody knew he would be getting a title shot at mania. However, NOBODY expected Cena to be IN THE RUMBLE, let alone win it, and the Undertakers win was deserving, because he is the friggin Undertaker.
I'm not saying that these weren't great Royal Rumbles, and I thought it was great to have Undertaker add one to his belt, but if the Royal Rumbles keep promoting the main eventers, they won't really get as exciting as when Rey won it, Batista or Benoit.
here is the list of Rumble winners 1992-2006:
92: Ric Flair (established as main eventer)
93: Yokozuna (unestablished as main eventer)
94: Bret Hart/Lex Luger (established as main eventer)
95: Shawn Michaels (unestablished as main eventer)
96: Michaels (still unestablished as main eventer, his mania match was the only main event between rumbles.
97: Stone Cold Steve Austin (unestablished as main eventer)
98: Austin (still unestablished, because he was still floating around the IC title scene til 98 rumble)
99: Mr. McMahon (unestablished as main eventer, however, that was a device to keep austin from winning 3 years in a row)
00: The Rock (established as main eventer)
01: Austin (established as main eventer)
02: HHH (established as main eventer)
03: Brock Lesnar (established as main eventer)
04: Chris Benoit (unestablished as main eventer)
05: Batista (unestablished as main eventer)
06: Rey Mysterio (unestablished as main eventer)
the history of past winners reveals phases where established guys win, then unestablished guys win. Maybe we go back to a string of unestablished guys winning for a while, but then that will grow old.
I'm just saying that for the next Royal Rumble, I'd love to see an upper midcard / midcard superstar win it, and get elevated big time.
Based on history, it should be, and I think WWE is ready for it. I personally would like to see it also.
Most midcarders I don't believe are ready for it, but there are some I'm SURE could use this push:
Lets run down your list.
If they go with an unestablished guy, then this is DEFINATELY the guy. He is over, has the amateur background, which works well in WWE, and is probably the next Brock Lesnar.
Another good choice
Finlay is never going to be main event. He is a guy used to put on good matches, and most likely couldn't carry the World title in the eyes of the fans.
He is getting over right now, if he keeps it up, he could be in the mix, because he seems to be future world champ material.
Never. He should have won it years ago, and it is too late now. His main detriment is his age/rumored readiness to retire. The Rumble Winner/new main eventer needs to be around long-term, which is Kane and Finlay's problem. I see him maybe getting a brief title run, but it won't be a rumble win/mania title match.
I can see him getting over and winning the 2011 Rumble, but I do not know if he will be able to get over before the 2010 rumble, especially since he is out right now.
MAYBE, if he can get massively over before January. The main problem is the fact that he is on ECW (and will be most likely until the next draft next year). I see Christian as a Money In The Bank winner, not a Rumble winner.
I love Hurricane Helms, but really, gimme a break. Why not let Santino win the Rumble. He at least has wrestled the past 6 months. Helms is awesome, but he will never get over enough to win the world title, especially since he is doing the Hurricane gimmick again.
Why does everyone think Shelton Benjamin is a Main Event waiting to happen. He has been given 179,438 chances to beak through. Each time he has embarrassed himself by not getting over, and sucking on the mic. He is a decent worker in the ring, and may even be an ECW champ type guy, but he is never gonna get over as a World Champ, yet alone a WrestleMania Main eventer. Yoshi Tatsu has a better chance of winning the Rumble, because he hasn't failed in the eyes of the fans yet.
These guys I think, with enough time put in, could be ready for a push like this. Just imagine it, for example I'll use Christain... Three men left in the ring, Mark Henry, Christain, Randy Orton. Christain is trying to push Mark Henry out the ring and it's about even, then Orton using his trademark sneakiness, throws them both over and celebrates, Christain although, is still hanging onto the rope! Pulls himself back in, then grabs Randy and throws him out with full power and recoils back onto his ass. Christain is stunned, Orton can't believe it and the crowd are over flowing with excitement! (Fart)...
What do you guys think?
Unfortunately, I see the fans overflowing with boredom at the idea of Christian winning the rumble (at least now). Also, as totallbc said, I am sick of that same false finish, which is used EVERY YEAR. and that is my problem with Royal Rumbles (and Battle Royals too). There is only a select few variations of over-the-top finishes, which is why I would rather see the last 2 have a 1-on-1 match right then and there (no DQ/countout).
my list of people I want to see win the Rumble:
Jack Swagger (I think he will be ready for it, and I also think he most likely will win the rumble this year)
The Miz
Chris Jericho (he really deserves the main event at Mania again)
Jeff Hardy (if he is still with the company)
HBK (he really should get one more title run)
CM Punk