I'm trying to figure out the logic behind Tanahasi beating Okada and making him look like a sniveling bitch. Anybody?
I think considering their ages, this is a story that NJPW can get away with selling right now.
The story has flow- Okada returns to the company immediately joins CHAOS, adopts the Rainmaker gimmick and is positioned as the young hot-shot challenging current ace Tanahashi right away.
He wins the belt and teases a changing of the guard, but shortly drops it back to Tanahashi.
He then goes on to win the G-1 and to prove to everyone that he is the new Ace, he says he wants his shot at Tanahashi at WK7, but Tanahshi wins there to maintain his spot on the mountain.
Still undeterred Okada wins the New Japan cup for another shot. He wins the match at Invasion Attack, and once again overcomes Tanahashi in the rematch in October, and cements his spot as Ace, with Tanahashi basically conceding and turning his attention to Nakamura and the IC belt.
In 2014 the introduction of AJ Styles to the main event, and taking Okada's belt while Tanahashi and Nakamura traded victories, muddied the waters, leaving the company with no clear Ace.
While Okada focused on the G1, winning it to get another shot at his title, Tanahashi crept into the picture, taking the belt off Styles, setting up a renewed battle at WK9 to prove who is the Ace.
Now they could've gone two ways- They could've had Okada go over and once again prove that he is above Tanahashi; OR go the route they went where Tanahashi shows that he took his defeats to Okada and grew and got even better and is now definitively the best again and deserves to still be the Ace. He puts guys like Nakamura and Styles on notice, further enhances his legacy as an all time great in the sport's history, and sets a new peak for Okada to climb if he is to ever regain the Ace position.
The way they went also allows them to set up a heel Okada up for a sympathetic face turn that likely leads to him leaving CHAOS and trying to topple Nakamura and show Tanahashi and the world that he's ready to prove beyond any doubt that he will be the Ace again.