I really thought the booking of No Way Out was crap... I just can't get it out of my head... I will elaborate...
1) SD Elim- Edge losing off the bat wasn't the bad thing, and it obviously set up for later in the night, but at that moment, I was convinced that HHH would win, and that is what I call a "buzzkill." How is it also that a match anything goes can a leg on a rope break a 3 count?
2) Orton vs Shane- That was booked like crap. The way they booked it, Shane should have a set of red "S" with blue backgroung Underoos on. A "hardly part-timer" having his way with the guy who is supposed to be the Number 1 contender on your flagship show? Then an RKO that sends Shane to ER? Had I booked it, Orton would have been so dominate, that the Kendo Stick would have been used for everything BUT make Shane into a human lollipop. Ultimately shouldn't have been a No DQ match if you are gonna let Shane go hardcore. Let Shane's "anger" cause a DQ then RKO has to defend himself, then set up the punt or RKO on Shane has Orton's way to combat the whole thing.
3) HBK vs JBL- Bad set up from the get go. I have said from the beginning that this feud makes no sense, and I stand by that. Why, though, would someone put their entire career on the line for a match you could be disqualified or counted out for? Make him fight for his life, not just a stipulation on another match to draw heat.
4) Swagger vs Finlay- First, if that was the Raw table taken down, I may have missed it, but why wasn't Lawler and Cole there when Shane took it out. Bad call on Grisham's part if I saw that right. Secondly, I would have had Christian come out and take them both out with a chair, making a double DQ, then grab a mic, saying something like "I took out Swagger before, so I know I can beat him" Something along those lines. By the way, had Christian shown up on SD, everyone and their brother would have read the spoiler and the thrill would have been gone instantly for those not at the show, so to disagree with most people, it's all in due time before I judge if Christian is being buried.
5) Raw Elim- I guess Edge wanted decaf Kofi. Seriously, Kofi had no reason to be in this match as a legitimate contender other than something like this. I know this is a hindsight thing, but how many others were even questioning his place in this match? All of us, I assume. Also, why did Kane want to take out Edge when he entered? And why no mention of the history between Jericho and Rey at the start of the match? Something, at least, like "This two know each other from years gone by" or some crap. I guess McMahon's "I didn't create it, so it doesn't exist" mantra would be the reason.
I think Cena may help on SD if he goes there, but as long as My Network isn't being shown in all markets, it doesn't matter. Unfortunately, ROH is about to find out the same.
While the overall show had surprises, once you got into watching it, the surprises let themselves out of the bag. I almost did the dastardly deal, and was about to watch TNA on the internet just to make myself feel better after the show.
As far as WM25 is concerned, flipping everything around that was supposedly building up all year is not the way to go for their biggest show of the year. Imagine this as well, fans: Triple H wins the biggest match of the night (if he is on Raw and it is the headliner), you will have Michael Cole making the "going off air" announcement. "Ye of wrestling's golf announcer voice" instead of "Good Ol'" JR. This, I am not looking forward to.
In closing, I will give this PPV a C-, because I believe some of the action was really good. The lack of storytelling, on the other hand, was what made it near failing.
Casey Carnage
http://www.carnagecrew.net