I think that most posts are about creative failing the wrestlers and ultimately the fans. The WWE as a whole will continue on, but to say the product right now is the best it's ever been is false.
It doesn't have the be the best it's ever been, since most entertainment companies go through slumps. The WWE is worth something like $1.5 billion, shares are trading high, they have the most viewed YouTube channel, they're in the top 5 streaming services, things in the WWE are going quite well.
With all the injuries and a lot of the big names out for months, it's not a surprise that they are having some issues. I've read recently they have had to rewrite the upcoming Wrestlemania, due to who's out.
There's absolutely zero reason to believe someone like Alvarez or Meltzer in times like this. They're either in on the work, or they're such marks for themselves that they make things up. Their actual success rate is extremely low when reporting things like this. I sincerely doubt that WrestleMania plans were even being jotted down at this point. The fans are so ridiculous in today's era, Roman Reigns will get EASILY the biggest pop of the night in one town, and booed out of a smark location. It's hard for creative because the fans make it hard for creative.
Rating's do matter. Apparently the USA network that airs RAW isn't happy. In the past year they've lost over a quarter of their viewers, and ratings are the lowest they've been in a decade. If you think that's a good thing then I don't know what to tell you. I don't think RAW will ever be cancelled, but advertisers who pay millions of dollars to the WWE might think twice before signing up again.
Ratings don't matter. At all. They're an archaic method of tracking television when record numbers of people are cutting the cord daily. USA Network desperately NEEDS WWE, the WWE doesn't need USA.
Let me explain further:
Ratings just don't matter like they used to. DVR, Hulu+, YouTube, all legal methods of getting content, that also include ad revenue. USA still thinks ratings matter because they are using a century old method of selling advertisement space on their television network. But they don't matter to the WWE who probably wouldn't lose much money if they just went exclusively to the WWE Network and made their content TV-14.
But, the top rated shows right now are millions and... MILLIONS of people lower than they were. At one point, in the late 90s, early 2000s, Friends expected 20 million people to tune in to see their new episodes. Under 20 million was a failure. Now, the top show, Big Bang Theory, can barely get 10 million. Yet, that show is still massively popular.
Television viewing is different. In the 90s, cable TV really wasn't much of anything. Now, on cable, you get Sons of Anarchy, Breaking Bad, Fargo, the show with Don Draper, whatever that was.
People don't consume media like they did a decade ago. Vince saw it, and revolutionized the game by creating the WWE Network and ensuring that USA will kiss his ass no matter what to keep his content on their channel.
Ratings don't matter because in 10 years, the whole system will be different again. I would wager that just as many people are watching WWE as used to watch WWE. They just get it on YouTube clips, Hulu+ recaps, and illegal streams.
Listen I'm the first person to praise Vince McMahon for what he has done with this company, and how he has built it up. But he is 70 odd now, and he is out of touch. We are seeing that week in and week out. He likes to put all his eggs in one basket, named John Cena. Which is not a bad thing, but Cena can't go on forever, and Vince's hand picked guy Roman Reigns isn't getting the reception he wants. God knows how long they are going to push him, and while they are doing it, the rest of the roster suffers.
This just isn't true. At all. John Cena was probably more over than Hogan was at one point. And since then, literally dozens of guys have been given the torch, they just can't hold it like Cena can.
Roman Reigns is super over. He gets gigantic pops in most towns, but the fans are the ones causing this problem.
And the rest of the roster hasn't shown any reason to be pushed. You want Ziggler, AGAIN? Miz, AGAIN? No, there are some unfortunate injuries, but Rollins was the Main Event for a long time. Ambrose fluctuates at the top. Cesaro has had tons of high profile matches, probably to get him ready for a real push, etc.
This isn't Vince's fault or Cena's fault. It's the fault of fans who believe that their individual opinion should dictate the show.
You just have to compare NXT and RAW to see how different the product is, and why a lot of people are tuning out on Monday nights, and watching NXT on Wednesdays. It's fresh approach, good matches and simple story lines have brought new viewers to the product, and older fans back. HHH is responsible for NXT, and to be honest I think Vince should move aside and let him take over the booking for the flagship show, or at least let him try. If Vince isn't happy he can take the reigns back again.
NXT is owned by Vince McMahon. It's ludicrous to believe that Vince is so super anal that he's involved with every single piece of the process in WWE, but the second largest federation in the USA that he ALSO owns, he doesn't do anything with. No, Vince is the decision maker for both WWE and NXT.
What NXT is is a way for Vince to drain the indys dry. They appeal to the smarks, they give good wrestling, they ignore stories, and they invest in spot monkeys, they even have a spot training ring at the Performance Center. The idea is the same idea that made the WWE the WWF back in the 80s. Buy out the competition. Vince is just working more marks than usual.
I do enjoy certain parts of the product, but other's are dismal, and yes they will get complained about. With such a good roster, injuries aside, there is no excuse for putting out what they do.
I find the WWE to be fun and entertaining. I watch Raw every Monday night, I watch each PPV, and I even come onto boards to talk about how good the product is. Sure, there are misfires, like Reigns v. Ambrose should have never gotten there, since they were having Sheamus take the belt anyway. It's a small thing, no big deal.
But it is truly a disorder that I cannot fathom to hate the WWE the way that many posters here or Wreddit, or whereever do, and STILL spend hours of their lives watching and seething.