THTRobtaylor
Once & Future Wrestlezone Columnist
I haven't checked out the podcast quite yet, hopefully I'll get a chance to do so later today after work (it's not Turkey Day up here in Canada, we had our Thanksgiving last month). But based upon the excerpts I have read and the comments here on the forums, nothing has really changed my opinion on the whole scenario.
If we take everything at face value (bearing in mind there are two sides to every story), he probably does have some justification to be pissed off and burned out mentally and physically. A lot of what he says would piss me off too if I were standing in his shoes. However, at the end of the day, I don't think it was appropriate and correct for him to walk away from his contract, which was going to be expiring in six months or so anyway. He should have informed the brass that he was unsatisfied and if things didn't change between then and the end of his contract, had would be leaving the company and not renewing a new deal. A contract is a commitment between both parties, yet he failed to honour his part of the deal. I'm sure he was well paid for his services while in WWE. Sure, money isn't everything, but that doesn't change the fact that he's been loving a comfortable lifestyle, financially speaking, thanks to WWE. Money doesn't buy happiness, but it damn well helps. All of these interviews, and supposed endorsements, and celebrity appearances (such as at Wrigley Field) all came his way because he was a contracted and famous WWE superstar. Regardless of his skill level, if he were toiling in obscurity in the Joe Blow Wrestling Federation, safe to say these opportunities would have been far scarcer. He reaped the benefits of being a top guy in the biggest worldwide professional wrestling company, the least he could have done was honoured his obligations back to them. Until his contract expires, and then he's free to do whatever he pleases.
He's been in the business a while. The pros and cons should have come as no surprise to him. When you sign on that dotted line, you agree to take all the pluses that come with it: the money, the fame, etc., But you have to be prepared to accept the minuses as well. Once you reach a point that you no longer want to do so, you can leave and do something else. Once your contract is up.
Athletes in pro sports do it all the time, and it pisses me off then too. They sign a 5 year 25M year contract, 5M per year. Then they have an awesome year and all of a sudden, they want more money. If you want the ability to renew your deal after 1 year, then don't sign a 5 year deal. If you have an off season, the team can't all of a sudden decide to pay him less, because there's a contract in place which has to be honoured. It should be a two way street. And same goes for Punk. If you weren't prepared to fulfill the obligations if the entire term of the contract, you shouldn't have signed it and reaped all of the benefits that came with it.
I understand Punk's frustration on many of the matters he discusses. But you shouldn't be able to bail out in your employer just because you're frustrated and unhappy. None of the rest of us regular Joes can do it, so why can he? Unless he has a feeling of entitlement and arrogance.
He covers this though... he's not an employee... but an independent contractor. This is Vince's problem, he wants to treat them AS employees for his purposes but not in the legal sense... Someone WILL challenge and win and by the sounds of it Punk very nearly was "that guy" but he is right... any WWE talent CAN walk at any time, they just can't then "walk back in" and it will cost them some dough in the short term. Look at Davey Boy Smith back in the post Montreal days, he ended up paying... not to quit, but to get rid of the no-compete. Guys who can afford to can walk any time, and if they're not planning on returning then it's not too much of an issue.
With 6 months on his deal, he was at that "now or never stage" where he had a lot less to lose money wise and would be covered by his injury had they tried to be clever and sue him... so he made the stand...just as Rey is doing.
If you're an employee of a company that is looking after it's people well and it's just you who has a beef, then you're more likely to do "the right thing". If they're fucking everyone over then you're not gonna even worry about fucking them if your health, sanity, marriage or life is at stake. He did the "decent thing" in that he didn't sue them, it's really the best Vince could hope for...if even half the stuff healthwise was true then they would be in serious breach of health and safety/duty of care allowing him to perform or pressuring him to do so.