Off the top of my head....
Rookie Of The Year: Dolph Ziggler's Gimmick. Small body of work, but when he posts it is always insightful and well-written.
The Mustang Sally Award aka Nicest Poster: ShinChan. Easiest nomination by far, just a super nice kid. RIP Mustang Sally.
Best Non-Spam Wrestling Poster: Bernkastel. Always well-researched and educational, particularly come Wrestlezone tournament time.
Best Non-Spam Non Wrestling Poster: Mitch Henessey. The MVP of the non-wrestling sections and appears to be an all-around good guy.
Thread Of The Year: When do you feel the WWE roster was at its all-time strongest?(Old School Wrestling). Tough to say because I haven't read a lot of the threads posted but this one stands out to me as one I really enjoyed.
Flying Under The Radar: stingray11214. Rarely starts any threads but consistently interjects intelligent and well-written posts.
Brass Ring Award: Not exactly sure what this is.
Best Thread Starter: LODemolition. Started a lot of the threads I enjoyed the most, he was particularly strong in the Old School section.
Best Section: Old School PPV/TV Reviews. Valuable tool for research and as a nearly endless source of entertainment when not much is going on elsewhere. Can't give enough credit to klunderbunker; though I often disagree with his opinions, he is a true workhorse there.
Best Staff Member: Dagger Dias. Very well-rounded member who is strong at posting in both wrestling and non-wrestling and also happens to be a friendly guy.
Funniest Poster: enviousdominous. Very sharp and very quick, he manages to be funny while also being extremely articulate.
Best Return: enviousdominous. Seems he was absent a fair chunk of the year. I always look forward to his posts, even if they are often 2 smart 4 me.
Get Your Ass Back Here: Gelgarin. Haven't interacted with him, he's been mostly absent since I started posting more regularly but when reading back over old threads his knowledge stands out.
Best Tournament: Wrestlezone tournament XI. Always this forum's highlight for me.
Best Meltdown: The Warlord. Got so ass-blasted he resorted to replying with "liberal snowflake vagina hat wearing male feminists". 'Nuff said.
Most Delusional Mark: Bill Lesnar, only because he refers to himself in the third person(even though it's just ironically). I get a kick out of his schtick, though.
Best Username: George Steele's Barber.
And I'm going to make up a category: Post of the Year. For this I nominate klunderbunker, who managed to name-drop both Tommy Rich and Warren Spahn in one post(KB Answers Wrestling Questions). A truly heroic effort.