Nate DaMac
Fuck erbody but me
You tell me, you're the one bringing up the consistency argument which doesn't mean anything in a battle between these guys at their primes. And the fact of the matter is, a booker WOULD put Prime Henry over Prime Benoit. Why? Because Benoit is exactly the kind of guy that would be added to the Hall of Pain. He was nothing more than an upper-midcarder in his own right. I'll think I'll choose the guy that was the guy on Smackdown for 6 months than a guy that was overshadowed by HHH, HBK, Evolution and Eugene during his title reign.
Do you not see how ridiculous you sound? Benoit may have been overshadowed by Hunter and Shawn, but at least he was a champion on the brand that mattered. Mark Henry was Champion on Smackdown in 2011, meaning Benoit was Champion on a show with twice the audience. If Benoit was overshadowed, Henry DEFINITELY was overshadowed. And Orton was still the man on Smackdown, Henry never came close to his popularity.