Lotta replies to get to, where to start.. why not the beginning.
Except that the fan reports always indicated that Swagger got the most heat BY FAR.
Front page has a new Smackdown "report" in. Swagger wasn't even listed in the top 3, including over that of a relative unknown, for "most heel heat". Now what.
I'm sure its one out of a dozen though, right? Could've happened to anyone. Just an off day, huh. Sure. I'm betting you, or someone, will come back with something cleaver.
For purpose sake of anything else - I'm simply saying, you claimed "by far" and I'm showing you a report thats
JUST come in, that shows him not even getting remote heat. And, you know, this should be a time when he should be at his most hated - considering he also fought Rey at this House show. :shrugs:
I don't buy the implication that "five star matches" (whatever those are) can't be had by a guy who runs like a pussy. It's a tried and true formula in wrestling and a form of storytelling. It still tickles man on occasion and does what it needs to. Why can't a "perfect match" be had from it?
I'm not trying to say a story can't be told within running and playing out the character you're suppose to be. Edge has made a living out of it, as pointed out.
I'm
saying that a stellar, MOTY quality match, can not be had by a guy who's ending it in DQ or countout. Which is what Swagger's done recently in his title defenses on Pay per view - when he isn't flatout losing in general.
I guess the definition of a
"perfect match" is viewed differently by everyone.
As for decent Swagger matches, his first ECW title defense against Christain (their second match against one another; on SciFi before Mania last year) is one of the best matches of last year. Of course Christian was one of the top three workers in the 'E last year for my money, so a bad match wasn't really an option. Still, it takes two to <some kind of dance>, and Swagger was one of the two men in that ring.
Hmm, I brought up asking someone to show me matches where he's been so great since winning the Heavyweight Championship - and you mention his ECW reign. Which is ironically enough the perfect example of what I'm talking about.
His best days,
are behind him, on a roster no longer there, that carried him.
As for his days as Heavyweight Champion, his match against Orton at Extreme Rules certainly wasn't awful. By any stretch.
Not awful. I wouldn't say any Swagger match is awful. Just because its not "great", doesn't make it bad. I think the majority of you that are trying to ride me, claim my view-point of Swagger is if it isn't a "great match" its an "awful match". Thats a piss-poor assessment of my thoughts.
His match with Orton was probably his best out of every one. And it was dry, with hardy any crowd interaction. And that of any there was - was for Orton. But I'm sure someone will claim it was Swagger.
Of course Swangle will prove he's not Angle when the bout fails to match Rey vs. Angle levels of greatness, but that's not a knock against Swagger.
Agreed. And furthermore, I'm not trying to completely throw Swagger under a bus. I'm merely saying he isn't a Champion worth remembering, and doesn't put on matches that will be considered "MOTY" come year's end.
I really am rubbing my eyes at this post. You're a seasoned vet who I understand to have superior knowledge of booking a heel especially being a huge mark for a guy who's made his career as being a sneaky, cowardly, weak little bitch, like Edge. Nothing against Edge, he's awesome. BUT a quick and easy way to get someone over as a heel is to umm, have them act like a heel. Swagger does this well, not as well as the likes of Edge, but then who could? Do you not hear the tremendous heat Swagger gets? It's not X-Pac heat, it's not hatred against the lisp, it's because he's played the heel role well. Alsooooo... with Show playing the role of the face, he is meant to be the badass that everyone is scared of. Mainly because he is you know, 7ft+ 500lbs. I can't think of a heel that's gone up against him that wasn't scared.
First; I'm not knocking the guy for his character. Never did. I have no clue where any of you got that wild accusation.
My main argument is against NorCal's absurdly funny comments that Swagger is putting on MOTY quality matches. And I fail to see how thats possible, when the majority of his matches all end in DQ's or Countouts.
He plays a quality heel role. He tries to cheat, he runs when he's defeated, he acts like a whimp/pussy almost every match - regardless how big or small his opponent is. Thats playing your character role to a Tee, and I'll never disagree with that.
Second; Where is this heat? I must have hearing loss or something because I'm apparently the only guy not hearing it. Either that, or the rest of you listen to your television very loudly and just believe what you're hearing is massive, when in reality - its just barely average
on full volume.
I do agree with the assertion though, that Swagger is NOT a main eventer. I had the same thoughts about Sheamus with his 1st title win, but he's done the work and won me over, and if booked correctly, Swagger will do the same. He won the title too early after winning MITB, but they had to book it that way, to make the MITB more exciting and credible. He has the tools, he's just a little green, that's all.
The thing is, Sheamus won a lot of people over because he proved he can put on entertaining matches with Triple H and John Cena, among others.
I chalk up part of Swagger's disappointing Main Event run due to lack of opponents. Chris Jericho & Edge would've been by far, his better opponents - and they both left upon him taking over the brand. (Likely, because had they of stayed - he never would've been taken seriously as the so-called 'top heel')
Kinda like, when a champion loses the belt, he as the right to a rematch. This is the rematch clause.
Not every Champion gets a rematch clause. Swagger should've been one of them.
I think the bigger question needs to be.. Where will Swagger go from here? Even if he wins, he's run out of opponents. (barring Kane or the Undertaker, which the match-up's on paper for those look completely squash-infested)
However, if/when he loses, where does he go from here? Mid-card obscurity.
Will you said your self you don't get SD!, and therefore don't get to see what Swagger has to offer on a weekly basis, that being said how in the blue fuck can you possibly offer a fair assessment of his reign?!?
Swagger did fine as a heel champion, he was SUPPOSE to look like a cowardly heel that would do anything to keep his title, booking a heel champion like this is nothing new, just in the last 10 fucking years they've done it with JBL, Triple H, Orton, Jericho, Punk and even your beloved Edge
Yes, and Punk's first reign was considered a massive failure. Just. Like. Swagger.
As for JBL, Triple H, Orton, Jericho & even
my beloved Edge. All of them have
WON several high profile Championship matches, and retained.
As far as Pay per view's go.. Swagger retained against Orton. Got DQ'd against a guy who's lost to Mysterio & Spike Dudley. And lost in a Fatal 4-Way where the theme of the night was
"opportunity". You'd have thought a Fatal 4-Way, where you can
steal a cheap victory (you know, like Miz did the Raw before), that Swagger would've had his best odds at winning.
Instead, Swagger was actually the guy who got pinned. There wasn't even a controversy around it. He just flatout LOST. Kane came in, took Punk out of the match - didn't touch Swagger. Big Show was laid out (by Mysterio, no less). And Swagger simply couldn't seize the moment and capitalize on any type of opportunity at hand.
And now there is suppose to be legit thought that Swagger could win a single's match?! Uhm, no.
you mind as well get used to seeing Swags in the ME, I have a feeling the guy is gonna be there for awhile, in fact I'll even go out on a limb and say Swags will be in the ME of a WM sometime in the next 5 years
Bold prediction there, Justin. The next
five years, in the Main Event. (of which I surely assume you mean, defending/challenging for a title from one of the brands, and not just "the" final match of the night.)
In 5 years, maybe he'll be what people have this illusion of him being now.