They think he is the second coming!
Yes, because that was the thrust of his message to us, no? He's been telling us he's the greatest wrestler on the planet and I find it ironic that many fans can "love" C.M. Punk while "hating" John Cena. With Cena, you get what you see, that's for sure. With Punk, no one knew what we were going to be seeing because he seemed to be exploring uncharted territory.
I didn't think he could sustain the kind of excitement and mystery he was bringing last Summer and, sure enough, he couldn't. Yes, he's still an interesting character, but it's hard to know what WWE "really" thinks about him because no one knows how much input Phil Brooks himself actually had into the development of his own character. Did he really threaten Vince McMahon with leaving, as illustrated in the dialogue between the two that appeared in an earlier post? Or has Punk just been an actor playing a role that was written for him by Creative?
Many folks on this forum claim to "know for a fact" that he did it all by himself (or not) but the fact is that no one knows for sure. It's hard to believe McMahon would allow someone to totally control his own on-air character when Vince wouldn't grant that exclusivity to anyone else. Are you going to tell me that guys like Triple H, Mick Foley and Steve Austin had to follow orders while Phil Brooks was allowed to dictate the direction of everything that involved him? I'll never believe that.
One speculation: If it was true that Punk really was dissatisfied with his role in WWE...... what if he had carried through his threat and left? Suppose Vince had let him leave? What would Punk be doing now? Would he be sitting cross-legged in the center of the ring in front of 150 fans at Wheeling Junior High in West Virginia, wondering how he could have overestimated his importance in the scheme of WWE programming? Or would WWE have had to close their doors because C.M. Punk had deserted them?
If you go strictly by ratings, you might say that Punk leaving had no effect, up or down. If you look at merchandise sales, maybe letting him go was a bad idea.
But I'll say this: Whether the whole "new direction" was Punk's idea, Creative's idea, or a combination of both......it sure was an exciting Summer. But after promising us he was going to turn the wrestling world upside down, I wonder what Punk is thinking now.