The PS3 is better, but it will only manifest itself in exclusive games. Publishers are historically reluctant to alienate half of their market by making a game that doesn't work properly on one console. I got bought a 360 when I got my A-Levels 4 years ago, and in the first three years it broke twice, one time was two weeks after the warranty ended, so I replaced it, not wanting to buy all the games again. Personally, I prefer the XBox through familiarity and I like the controller better and, ironically, because my PS2 broke and I never really forgave Sony, but the objective better console is the PS3. If they are the same price, I'd recommend the PS3.