I would say just normal really. Might be because I'm a Triple H mark, but generally this guy delivers when needed to.
Some are obviously high in hate about the fact that he has 13 world title reigns, and there's a few people here and there that didn't get over through the momentum they had building up alongside him when the feud was over.
But Triple H is overall a great wrestler, he has a great look that you cannot deny, he has a great ability to make the crowd hate or love him through his fantastic microphone skills, as well as he has some pretty good in-ring abilities.
Sure Triple H's in-ring abilities died down a bit after 2 quad tears, but can you honestly blame the guy? He have gotten back every time and continued to deliver through pretty good matches, and great intense feuds with pretty much all of the top guys. You all complain about him being in the main event and in the title picture. But have anybody ever considered it's because he's able to make it work? I have never felt that he had a bad feud, at least not the ones that mattered. And it's because Triple H is just that damn good.
I wouldn't call him overrated, because he has scratched and clawed his way to the top. And that's not a lie, he was on the way to the top before he had anything with Stephanie McMahon, so he was definitely warranted for success eventually. The success might very well have been bigger due to Stephanie, but he would've still been a surefire Hall of Fame inductee with, or without Stephanie McMahon.
And he's not underrated, because he still gets praise worthy of him here and there. As well as there might be a few reigns here and there that weren't completely warranted, but the majority are ones that made sense, as well as ones that he has earned.