Hell everyone, Ive decided to make a thread which hasnt been done on here in the past to my knowledge. Now this thread is not opinion, this thread is meant to see whom should be on the Top Ten Most Powerful Superheroes list.
When I say its not opinion I am saying it must be based on cannon feats of the hero in question, not opinion of what they could do (without any feats backing it up) or liking of one over another.
For example, if you say for instance "I think Hulk should be number 5" I want you to make an argument based upon his feats for that spot AND compare and contrast them to everyone else below the spot. If their feats/powers are not greater than that of the one who's spot they are attempting to take they will not go in.
Now a heroes powers also do figure into this, and the depth of those powers shown via feats or cannon panels/characters stating the depths of their power (and try to use credible characters not like a little girl stating "his power must be infinite"). Quantity helps a lot when it comes to powers, however they must also have quality, and those powers must still be canon/be usable for the character.
I will start with an original list, your job must be to make it so you can prove a case for a character to be placed onto the list, or to move up or down a character, or to remove them in place of another, or defend their placement.
Now as for restrictions on this list: We are only using Classic/Modern (Modern for DC as they has Crisis on Infinite Earths, though some feats prior and the event itself are actually still cannon or have been made cannon again, so youll have to make sure to do your research) or basic form heroes. So this means No Pre-Crisis Superman, no Rune King Thor, no Keeper of The Rock Captain Marvel, No War Hulk with celestial technology, No Monarch for Captain Atom, not Fernus for Martian Manhunter, etc. Also Ultimate version of Marvel heroes do not count as theyre not cannon. Also I am not going to allow exorbitantly powerful beings or celestials, so this means no Odin, Spectre, Dark Pheonix, Highfather etc. No Super Villains obviously as this list is for Superheroes. This way it makes the list fair, as we dont want any omnipotent beings that just beat everyone on the list.
So for now the original list shall be the following, I will include a brief summery of each heroes powers:
1: Superman
Powers: Super strength according to his will which is infinite, super speed, invulnerability, heat vision, freeze breath, x ray vision, torquasm vo and rao, energy absorption, electro magnetic forcefield.
2: Captain Marvel
Powers: Seemingly infinite super strength, invulnerability, super speed, magic powers, healing, can share powers.
3: Thor
Powers: Super strength, invulnerability, magic powers, flight, energy absorption, warrior madness, belt which doubles strength.
4: Silver Surfer
Powers: Power cosmic, energy manipulation, energy draining, teleportation, flight, healing, amping.
5: Spawn
Powers: Super strength, magic healing factor, immortality, necro powers, elemental manipulation, and flight.
6: Captain Atom
Powers: Matter manipulation, energy manipulation, super strength, flight, time travel, can absorb theoretically infinite energy proportional to his will, energy blasts or explosions, ability to survive in space, quantum field manipulation.
7: Flash
Powers: Super speed, phasing, can control others speed, time travel, flight, and speedforce manipulation.
8: Green Lantern: Kyle Rayner
Powers: Energy Manipulation, flight, energy shield, energy constructs, matter manipulation.
9: Martian Manhunter
Powers: Total control over atomic structure allowing intangibility, mass increase, and shape shifting. Martian Vision, Flight, Healing factor, super strength, and telepathy.
10: Hulk
Powers: Strength, endurance, and speed directly proportional to his stress level, which is without limit. Healing factor, Ability to breath under water, adaptability.
Now I wont be posting feats, as that will be up to you to make your arguments for whom should stay, go etc.
Now when you make your arguments remember, this is a non spam section, so make sure to give details and a good argument for why exactly your hero should stay on here, be moved, or be placed onto here. I would also like to see scans of feats, as I wont be simply taking word of mouth over everything else. If you think it may be too much to post them all as Images simply supply the working links.
Now I know stuff like this tends to get heated, but remember, its just comics and its all in good fun. Now you may begin your arguments.
When I say its not opinion I am saying it must be based on cannon feats of the hero in question, not opinion of what they could do (without any feats backing it up) or liking of one over another.
For example, if you say for instance "I think Hulk should be number 5" I want you to make an argument based upon his feats for that spot AND compare and contrast them to everyone else below the spot. If their feats/powers are not greater than that of the one who's spot they are attempting to take they will not go in.
Now a heroes powers also do figure into this, and the depth of those powers shown via feats or cannon panels/characters stating the depths of their power (and try to use credible characters not like a little girl stating "his power must be infinite"). Quantity helps a lot when it comes to powers, however they must also have quality, and those powers must still be canon/be usable for the character.
I will start with an original list, your job must be to make it so you can prove a case for a character to be placed onto the list, or to move up or down a character, or to remove them in place of another, or defend their placement.
Now as for restrictions on this list: We are only using Classic/Modern (Modern for DC as they has Crisis on Infinite Earths, though some feats prior and the event itself are actually still cannon or have been made cannon again, so youll have to make sure to do your research) or basic form heroes. So this means No Pre-Crisis Superman, no Rune King Thor, no Keeper of The Rock Captain Marvel, No War Hulk with celestial technology, No Monarch for Captain Atom, not Fernus for Martian Manhunter, etc. Also Ultimate version of Marvel heroes do not count as theyre not cannon. Also I am not going to allow exorbitantly powerful beings or celestials, so this means no Odin, Spectre, Dark Pheonix, Highfather etc. No Super Villains obviously as this list is for Superheroes. This way it makes the list fair, as we dont want any omnipotent beings that just beat everyone on the list.
So for now the original list shall be the following, I will include a brief summery of each heroes powers:
1: Superman

Powers: Super strength according to his will which is infinite, super speed, invulnerability, heat vision, freeze breath, x ray vision, torquasm vo and rao, energy absorption, electro magnetic forcefield.
2: Captain Marvel

Powers: Seemingly infinite super strength, invulnerability, super speed, magic powers, healing, can share powers.
3: Thor

Powers: Super strength, invulnerability, magic powers, flight, energy absorption, warrior madness, belt which doubles strength.
4: Silver Surfer

Powers: Power cosmic, energy manipulation, energy draining, teleportation, flight, healing, amping.
5: Spawn

Powers: Super strength, magic healing factor, immortality, necro powers, elemental manipulation, and flight.
6: Captain Atom

Powers: Matter manipulation, energy manipulation, super strength, flight, time travel, can absorb theoretically infinite energy proportional to his will, energy blasts or explosions, ability to survive in space, quantum field manipulation.
7: Flash

Powers: Super speed, phasing, can control others speed, time travel, flight, and speedforce manipulation.
8: Green Lantern: Kyle Rayner

Powers: Energy Manipulation, flight, energy shield, energy constructs, matter manipulation.
9: Martian Manhunter

Powers: Total control over atomic structure allowing intangibility, mass increase, and shape shifting. Martian Vision, Flight, Healing factor, super strength, and telepathy.
10: Hulk

Powers: Strength, endurance, and speed directly proportional to his stress level, which is without limit. Healing factor, Ability to breath under water, adaptability.
Now I wont be posting feats, as that will be up to you to make your arguments for whom should stay, go etc.
Now when you make your arguments remember, this is a non spam section, so make sure to give details and a good argument for why exactly your hero should stay on here, be moved, or be placed onto here. I would also like to see scans of feats, as I wont be simply taking word of mouth over everything else. If you think it may be too much to post them all as Images simply supply the working links.
Now I know stuff like this tends to get heated, but remember, its just comics and its all in good fun. Now you may begin your arguments.