I'm reading down this thread, and not one single bit of evidence, not one single point can convince me that Matt Hardy deserves a main event push of any kind. He's had his chances, numerous in fact. At his peak in 2005, he really should have been taking the huge opportunity of the Edge feud and utilising it. No go. In 2007, he had a stellar feud with MVP, and he should have used that to elevate himself. An injury later and he fizzles out. In fact, it was an exact replica of his feud with his brother. A feud he won, only to be ruined by an injury. And still, no one could have cared less about him, even after brutally attacking and beating the arguably top face in the company.
The fact of the matter is, Matt Hardy isn't that interesting. If all the heat that he has dies out with him not being on TV, I think that shows that the fans just don't hold that high an interest in him. the only interest they held was in his last name after Jeff left, but the fact of the matter is, they realised he wasn't as interesting. Coupled with the fact that he has been wishy washy with his alignment in terms of a face turn, I seriously doubt his abilities to really get over. He was at home on ECW, champion of the C show, and in my mind, thats where Matt Hardy should have stayed.