My opinion of Matt Hardy, ignoring all backstage issues and his recent videos (which, like most people, have negatively effected my opinion of him):
As a tag team wrestler, Matt Hardy was very good in his prime. A more well-rounded worker than Jeff; he was genuinely quick in his day, and was capable of good, but not spectacular ground-based work and a bit of high flying stuff as well. For his part, Jeff was more charismatic, and was a spot-machine (I don't mean that as a criticism, it's an objective statement). The result was that they complimented each other nicely; Matt carried the bulk of the actual ring-work (which stopped their matches from becomming messy spotfests) while Jeff would come into the ring in short bursts to do the insane spots that people so strongly identify with the Hardys. Matt's strength was that he was quick enough and capable of a bit of high flying stuff himself, so he kept things flowing and made it so that the Hardys matches were always fast paced. They were excellent to watch in their day. Anyone who's being objective would acknowledge that as a tag team, the Hardys deserve an eventual HOF spot, both for their importance and the quality of their work.
As a singles wrestler he wasnt nearly as good. Being a solid but unspectacular ring worker was fine as a tag team wrestler, because his job was to keep things moving and provide a foundation/context for Jeffs high spots. As a singles wrestler, though, it hurt him, because he had nothing to build up to; no cool moves of his own to give his matches a climax. He is also absolutely robotic on the mic, often to the point of being painful to watch. This really limited his ability to take part in main event level feuds, and I'm sure it's a big reason why he never got "that big push", despite being more over than other guys who did.
I'm tempted to argue that he has no charisma, as I find him bland as fuck, but to be fair, he always got major pops even at the end of his WWE run. You cant entirely put this down to being Jeff's brother; he was still getting giant pops long after their breakup. I guess this -along with the fact that he was always a reliably solid worker until a couple of years ago- is the reason he was able to forge a modestly successful singles career, with the occasional memorable feud (MVP and Edge come to mind). However, a strong midcard spot was all he was ever going to get, and was all he deserved.
So, yeah, as a wrestler, that's my opinion of Matt Hardy. In a nutshell; he was a highly accomplished tag team wrestler and a decent but limited singles wrestler, who successfully held down a strong midcard spot but never had the makings of a main event wrestler. I also think that currently, he looks like a parody of his former self. He is -in theory- easily young enough to get in shape, get motivated and become decent again, whether he actually does it or not is a whole 'nother thing.
As a tag team wrestler, Matt Hardy was very good in his prime. A more well-rounded worker than Jeff; he was genuinely quick in his day, and was capable of good, but not spectacular ground-based work and a bit of high flying stuff as well. For his part, Jeff was more charismatic, and was a spot-machine (I don't mean that as a criticism, it's an objective statement). The result was that they complimented each other nicely; Matt carried the bulk of the actual ring-work (which stopped their matches from becomming messy spotfests) while Jeff would come into the ring in short bursts to do the insane spots that people so strongly identify with the Hardys. Matt's strength was that he was quick enough and capable of a bit of high flying stuff himself, so he kept things flowing and made it so that the Hardys matches were always fast paced. They were excellent to watch in their day. Anyone who's being objective would acknowledge that as a tag team, the Hardys deserve an eventual HOF spot, both for their importance and the quality of their work.
As a singles wrestler he wasnt nearly as good. Being a solid but unspectacular ring worker was fine as a tag team wrestler, because his job was to keep things moving and provide a foundation/context for Jeffs high spots. As a singles wrestler, though, it hurt him, because he had nothing to build up to; no cool moves of his own to give his matches a climax. He is also absolutely robotic on the mic, often to the point of being painful to watch. This really limited his ability to take part in main event level feuds, and I'm sure it's a big reason why he never got "that big push", despite being more over than other guys who did.
I'm tempted to argue that he has no charisma, as I find him bland as fuck, but to be fair, he always got major pops even at the end of his WWE run. You cant entirely put this down to being Jeff's brother; he was still getting giant pops long after their breakup. I guess this -along with the fact that he was always a reliably solid worker until a couple of years ago- is the reason he was able to forge a modestly successful singles career, with the occasional memorable feud (MVP and Edge come to mind). However, a strong midcard spot was all he was ever going to get, and was all he deserved.
So, yeah, as a wrestler, that's my opinion of Matt Hardy. In a nutshell; he was a highly accomplished tag team wrestler and a decent but limited singles wrestler, who successfully held down a strong midcard spot but never had the makings of a main event wrestler. I also think that currently, he looks like a parody of his former self. He is -in theory- easily young enough to get in shape, get motivated and become decent again, whether he actually does it or not is a whole 'nother thing.