I am going to try and be as non-biased as possible when it comes to this post. But the MEM is probably the dumbest thing ever. For multiple reasons, I am going to go over each member, their role on why they are there and lastly, if I remember, continuity issues with the Stable it's self.
First, Lets take a look at each Member:
Sting - They have tried to make Sting heel before (WCW) and it didn't work. So they tried to make him the head of a heel stable and hope it'd pay off. So he'd cut promo's and name drop in order to say "I'm here because of these people" but instead he gets face pops.
So now they are making Kurt Angle and to a lesser extent Booker T draw the heat to the stable. Which is fine, but out of all the people in the group, Sting sticks out the most when it comes to the stable. He just doesn't fit.
They are having him not jump in on the beat downs for one of 2 reasons that I agree with a lot which was posted on this site earlier:
They are trying to make him look like a "god father" type figure and does all this so "blood isn't on his hands" and all that bs or. They are going to turn him baby face and have him join the TNA Originals/whatever they are going to be called with in the next two tapings.
How the second option would happen is pretty much classic cut, it happens with every stable that has too many top or would be top people (Evolution, nWo, whoever else) one person (Angle) will try to flex his leadership muscles, do stuff the leader of the stable (Sting) didn't condone they will have their tuft and the stable will be divided and ended up splitting or feuding with in each other (Think Wolf Pac vs nWo Hollywood but not such a cluster
fuck of fail)
Now onto why Sting shouldnt actually be in the Stable is this:
He has no reason to be there. He wont do house shows, he isnt going on the UK tour. He appears maybe 2-3 times a year, wins the titles then drops it to someone (usually the exact person he won it against) then goes back home to leech off the company. I honestly think Sting is ruining TNA. I use to be a huge sting mark. But all the shit you hear and read about sting since hes been signed to TNA just pisses me off and made me lose all respect I had for him as a performer. He is lazy, self centered and is just leeching money off of Spike TV and TNA. When his contract expires (iirc he wasnt even a full contract) they shouldnt re-hire him. He has no right being on TNA. He became everything he hated about WCW end days. People like Hogan and co. didnt want to give their spots to the younger guys and neither does Sting.
Not to mention every match I have seen sting in since last year he has shown massive ring rust and the other people would have to carry him the entire match. Also the SDD is a shitty finisher. Use the scorpion deathlock more.
All in all, Sting just doesn't belong. In the Stable, or in the wrestling business in general. Fuck Sting.
Booker T: The only reason I really feel he is in this stable is because they had nothing for him creativity wise, so they just stuck him in there and created the legends belt so he could draw heat. The African king gimmick/royal T, whatever they are trying to do is fucking stupid. All they did is re-hash and ruin a GREAT gimmick he had in WWE. But it doesn't work in TNA because there was an actual story behind why he was acting like that. In TNA he was normal, talked normal, then all the sudden ***** comes out in a cape and starts calling himself Royal T and speaking with a really bad accent.
Yes, I understand he is a 5-time (5-time, 5-time, 5-time, 5-time) champion. But he wasn't feuding with any of the Youngin's/Originals. So to throw him in there didn't make sense to me. So, to re-iterate, he is there due to lack of creative idea's backstage with him, but since he is getting a rather fatty check. they wanted him in the spot light (just like every other ex wcw/wwe guy there)
Nash:
Nash is the only character I can really understand on why he would be in the Stable. He had all the vignettes with Shelly and the X-Division guys, had the Stable with Shelly, and the legit heat with Samoa Joe due to the Hall incident and Hall no showing. And them playing that off in their feud/reason the stable exists was VERY smart from a creative writing aspect. I really have no gripes with Nash being in the group. Except he shouldn't be wrestling anymore his knee's are going to explode any second and he will be confined to a wheel chair.
I appreciate how Nash looks in the group though. he stands above everyone and gives off a very bold and convincing "Strong but silent type and legitimately looks like he is going to punch your teeth in. He needs to stay that way. Like how Steiner is the main muscle for the stable (though I don't agree with this and I'll explain why in a moment) that's all Nash should be. The strong and silent type Muscle character of the stable that gets to put the "nail in the coffin" (I.E. Jack knife power bomb) and call in the hits for the group.
Scott Steiner:
When the fuck has Steiner ever been a top carder? Ever? Aside from when he was with his brother and the tag team division was actually a respectful branch of the wrestling industry? He sucks on the mic, has never been a top carder, he botches constantly, he doesn't protect people when doing high impact moves (His match vs. Rhyno last week proves this. After his second belly to back suplex he gave rhyno, he [rhyno] landed really badly on his head and neck and was holding it the rest of the match outside of the gore). Although Steiner is a huge body. That's all he is. He doesn't belong in the group. At all. The only other person I could see taking his place would be Tomko due to him and AJ's rivalry. But along with no longer being with the company, Tomko was never a World Champion and he'd stick out pretty bad. Just like Steiner.
And lastly, we get to Kurt with a broken friggin neck! MILK! Angle:
This guy is easily one of the most talented wrestlers in the business. Pre and Post-Crisis versions of Angle. This man is pure, raw, talent. I can see why they wanted him TNA. They got a lot of exposure when they signed Angle and I respect TNA for that. Sting and Angle are 2 of the main reasons Spike picked up Impact!. And like Nash, Angle actually belongs in this group.
Here is why. He has had rivalries with BOTH AJ and Joe who are heading the TNA Originals/Frontliners (fuck Rhyno). He has a reason to be in the Stable and I honestly think he should be the leader/god father type figure and not Sting. Angle is far more aggressive, far more tactical (staring down from the rafters or a bird isnt omg mindfuck tactics. Sorry) and he knows how to tell a story via promos and in-ring performance. He has the ability to carry a feud with anybody. Not many people can do that. So putting him in a stable like this was a great idea. Team Angle IMO was a stupid idea cause it was like Cena in the WWE but a heel burying everyone instead of face.
Although, I disagree with the fact he is feuding with Jarrett while in the stable. That shit should have been separate and could have been built by its self, even though I think its just for ratings/Jarrett is bored/wants to bury angle for shit he said in the UK Sun a few months back.
Now, here are the inconsistencies/continuity problems with the stable:
This is my main one, and kinda only one. The whole Kurt Angle and Sting alliance thing. Does no one remember their feud they had where Krazy Kurt was all like yes pedo and stalked Stings kid and all that stupid shit? Now all the sudden they are buddy buddy? GTFO with that stupid shit. Yes, I understand they can retcon shit if they want (how many times have HHH/HBK feuded?) but that feud is still fresh in every ones mind and It just doesnt make sense.
I would say a continuity problem would be Angle/Nash siding with each other too, but since they both have beef with Joe. It make sense.
Now the random gripes:
The name of the stable sucks. The music sucks, the only thing that is gratifying out of this is that Sting does look like a fucking pimp in a suit. He looks like a glorified bad ass. I wouldnt fuck with him.
I will probably add more/edit this when I can. But this is all mostly from off the top of my head. So you can bitch at me, call me a dumb ass, a WWE mark (they arent perfect either but thats for another time and place), whatever you want. But thats not the case, its just an unbiased (as possible) reflection of the stable.
Also, this is my first post on this forum so I hope this post leaves albeit a mixed impression, a good/positive one.
Thanks for reading.