Take into consideration this as well, I was World Champion for an entire calendar year. That set back a lot of guys that could be argued that could have held the world title a hell of a lot sooner in their careers, take into consideration Showtime, Big Dave, Barbosa, you could argue Blade was due, and in the mean time others rose up, such as Holmes, Kurtesy, Constantine, Kravinoff, the list goes on, while still having Titus and Everest around that could be thrown in for a shot as well.
As you said, a year in this fed is not as much action as in the WWE where they have that many PPVs. So you push all those guys that should have been champ sooner back a year, it sort of left those later risers as Rush and Smith on the outside looking in. I can't speak a whole lot on why they didn't get a shot as I was on Creative for a cup of coffee the second time around before they left, but I'm sure the time table didn't help any.
The first part kind of flows into my point. You had a year long reign because you deserved it. But then we have a group of guys that never got around to getting a shot because of the lag in opportunity.
Guys like Smith and Rush didn't get a crack at the top because guys like Drake, Holmes, and Showtime still had unfinished business to deal with. It would have been a shame to not give them that platform to finish it. However, you have the problem of the guys waiting in the wing for their shot. An additional top tier prize would have done wonders to appease them.
Plus, with guys like Titus occasionally showing up, it would be nice to set him up against a heel for one title, but not feel bad for those that consistently RP on a round-by-round basis who have to wait their turn behind a part-timer.
I have to disagree with you, Kermit, on an out-of-character level for two reasons.
I have never been a singles champion in the fed. I know the day if/when that happens will feel awesome, and I'm sure there are others that agree with me. From that perspective, guys like Crock and Merk did reach a level that a lot of guys haven't and should both feel accomplished and be recognized for that achievement. I agree that they should've gotten World Title shots (although they both kind of choked in the Lottery that year if I remember correctly) but their runs with the Elite X and EurAsian Titles will be remembered for a lot longer than a failed World Title match ever would.
For others, being the World Champion is the goal. Hell, I'd argue that at least 95% of people have that as their ultimate goal. By making a second title at that level, it may not water it down on-screen, but I'd argue that a big part of the prestige from an OOC perspective is gone. Imagine if there was a second top tier title during Ty's year long reign: what would that have changed? Ty still would've been the undisputed best in the fed; at best, the other champ would've been at the level of Showtime or whomever the top challenger was at the time.
I agree. Rush and Smith both did a lot with the ball they were given, but there comes a time when a guy has outgrown the current teir he is in. For the likes of Rush and Smith, there was nowhere to put them with KFAD moving to Apocalypse so they were put in a makeshift program with Saboteur and Saxton. Granted, all four of those guys were on about equal levels, but they were practically begging for something bigger like a world title shot. Also, I would not fault them for flaking in the lottery. That thing is always a mixed bag.
In terms of OOC prestige, I kind of understand what you are saying, but I think that the "devaluation" of the second world title is mainly based on opinion and how creative treats the two. For instance, if Black Dragon had risen to the top and brandished a second world title at the time of Ty Burna's reign. I would honestly have put both them on a pretty similar level RP-wise.
In an opposite scenario (I'm sorry Pancake) I don't think many people really thought Pancake was the best RPer during his world title reign. If we are talking about OOC wise? Why don't we discuss that rarely do we see guys on hot streaks get pulled up for a title match in an appropriate time? They are noticed and put on a waiting list. Then we punish them for fizzling out because lack of clear direction. That's the product of Sam Smith and Rush. An additional top tier title provides an additional outlet that we could plug those individuals into.
If the choice requires a very small diminish in prestige over who is the "true" top champion so that some guys who deserve an opportunity actually get one or two in this life time, I would be fine with it. I actually want to see guys like Theron Daggershield or Alhazred get a shot before I call it a day here. However, at the current rate we are going it is more likely that they hang up their e-boots or a couple years pass before that ever happens.
It's not Creative's fault. There is just a lot of guys and only one top title.
2 World titles were done. But it didn't pan out due to the same stigma that eventually killed the World Heavyweight Championship in WWE. 2 World titles under the same brand will just never be equals. I still remember when the Eurasian and Elite X titles were equals on opposite shows. But then Bug Dave won the EA title and it became a bigger deal.
All we can do is more title shots.
I think it falls back on how Creative portrays them really. Look at the world title before its unification to the WWE title. They put it on John Cena and it suddenly gained a huge increase in spotlight. It all just depends on who is holding it and how Creative chooses to present it. If they favor one and subject the other to constant second-tier exposure, sure it will look a lot weaker.
With that being said, they lived with the titles being separate for several years and made it work.

Are we not willing to do the same, at a minor cost of prestige, so some guys like S.H.I.T., Holmes, and Constantine can compete for world titles consistently?
In the end it's not my decision, but I think it is something worth looking at least. Miko's list is alarming in terms of guys who never got a shot, or messed up a single shot and dropped down a long way on the ladder. We also don't have the luxury of hot-shotting a new guy or returning legend into the world title scene purely based on momentum because there are so many waiting in line. Maybe an additional world title could grant the fed some of those opportunities.
Who knows? Maybe I am just a crazy frog.
Where do you think the Chris KO/Dustin Hunter thing we had going would've ended up going if we both didn't end up leaving the fed?
What do you think I can do to fix Lexi? I still see a lot of potential in the character but I'm at a total dead end of what to do with her.
What's your favorite RP you ever wrote?
I planned on feuding with you before Falk's sudden departure. I wanted to take a role on the lower part of the card, but also help some of the younger guys (you, mostly) develop into a more consistent player in the mid-card.
I honestly have not read your character much, except for the PPV preview shows that I did. I think there is still a lot of potential in a heel turn/LOL speak persona.
My favorite? Either my RP against Ty at Redemption or my RP against Titus at Kingdom Come V. As a guilty pleasure, there was an RP I wrote one time during the initial negative criticism surrounding the White Knight gimmick.
It was back when everyone was criticizing how Chris appeared on TV, but were not reading my RPs to really see how my character was struggling with the persona that was kind of forced upon him. In the RP, Kensworth, Madison, and Klamor all told their version of a dirtsheet story they heard about Chris K.O. that involved him saving a cat from a tree. Klamor's version had Chris punting the cat post-rescue and Madison's version had Chris shirtless.
I thought it was pretty clever for what was surrounding my character, but I don't think Creative liked it.
You spoke frequently on your podcast of a disconnect in my RP's. Are they better now that Theron speaks more often of the shows and the championships? The reason for all the differing names and completely different world is that this is how he legitimately in character sees the world. I felt that when creative began writing him as using the names of his world's counterparts in promos removed the disconnect. Do you agree or disagree?
And an easier question.... How would you see a Theron VS Haven or Chris feud going?
The last I read of Theron was at LL. I thought you were going to beat Constantine (I think I predicted that). From what I read before and then at the LL, I saw some improvement in erasing the disconnect. Creative incorporating RP material on the actual TV shows always helps a character.
That being said, there are some guys whose work just reads better in bulk. A guy like Steven Holmes is a good example. You really have to read a lot of his work consistently to appreciate his grasp on the character. I think I have said it before, but that is the type of character Theron is to me.
Oh man, I think the first one was an easier question. It seems in both scenarios that it would be a good-hearted rivalry in each feud. Chris vs. Theron would probably devolve into a respect match. Haven vs. Theron might be founded on some type of mix up. Honestly, both of those feuds just seem really improbably without someone turning heel or setting up for a heel turn.