I agree that Nikki is not a better wrestler than any of the 3 recent NXT callups....but she's better than most of the rest of the roster.
I would also say of the 3 NXT callups.....Sasha is the only one who's character is really there right now IMO, and she's done that in fairly limited time. But she just has "it" and it's obvious.
Becky....she really hasn't had a chance to show much yet. She may be fantastic in the ring, but she needs a chance to grow(meaning some character development and more solo matches) before she becomes a contender.
And Charlotte.....I think he's a phenomenal athlete and good in the ring. I like her.....but her character isn't there yet. I'm not sure the time is right for her to win the title. Frankly I don't think Paige winning the title before she had developed any kind of character, did her any favors.
I think they would be better off having Nikki retain on Sunday, but continuing or better yet.....starting the feud with Charlotte. Let Charlotte chase it for a while, let an actual feud develop.....THAT'S what leads to character development and that's what gets the fans invested. When Charlotte finally wins the title(maybe at Survivor Series?), there's a bigger payoff, and she's more ready character wise.
And I agree with you that out of the three NXT girls Sasha is the most ready. The WWE has screwed this whole thing up. Instead of giving these girls the time they've already spent there to develop characters, they've had them quite frankly in a muddled mess.
But I disagree that the fans aren't invested in this. They want to see Nikki Bella lose that belt. Being the longest reigning anything doesn't equate to being the best. Out of a division where there were only 3 real girls with the chance of holding that title, Nikki Bella wasn't the best. Paige and Naomi were both better in the ring than she was.
The problem with that was Paige has already held the title a couple of times, Naomi went into that horrible heel turn, and left Alicia Fox and Tamina, both of whom are dismal.
But like I said before the landscape has now changed, and we have 3 women who at any time could be Diva's champion and would be believable. Nikki Bella holding the title till Survivor Series, would be like her coming in second in a beauty pageant and the other three coming in first. And she would still be announced the winner.
This is a chance for the WWE to finally in a long time fix the fuck ups with the women's division. They started out on a sour note, but there is time to redeem it. I'm just afraid they won't. There is no point in these women learning the ropes in NXT, putting on main event matches there and coming up to the bullshit on the main roster. Everyone is a loser when that happens.